Faster access to SaReGaMaPa Challenge 2007
Get faster internet speeds by using

Winner of SaReGaMaPa - Aneek Dhar

Aneek Dhar has won SaReGaMaPa Challenge 2007

The winner of Saregamapa Challenge 2007 is Aneek Dhar of Himesh Reshammiya’s Rock Gharana..Â Â

1stÂ Runner Up of the show is Raja Hasan of Vishal Shekhar’s - Hit Squad Gharana..

2nd Runner Up is Amanat Ali of Ismail Darbar’s Yalgar Gharana

Loading …

SaReGamaPa Challenge 2007

October 13, 2007 |

Comments

241 Responses to “Winner of SaReGaMaPa - Aneek Dhar”

Aanshi on October 23rd, 2007 4:54 pm

sg2007.. You can try and download all these songs.. they play much better in wimamp player or anyother player you might be having on my computer..

http://saregamapachallenge2007.com/challenger-performances-aneek-dhar.html

Here you can find all the files for download..

Reply to this comment
sg2007 on October 23rd, 2007 3:05 pm

But thanks a lot!!!! would like to know if the 2005 archives are available esp. Nihira Hemachandra and Vineet

Reply to this comment
sg2007 on October 23rd, 2007 3:03 pm

Hi Aanshi http://www.saregamapachallenge2007.com/aneek-dhar-performances.html

the speed is a little slow - is it my internet speed or is it the original recording. Actually, it makes Aneek sound like a man

Reply to this comment
swie on October 16th, 2007 10:25 pm

amanat is the best singer of saregamapa n no one can change that fact of life..

i am neither from india nor pakistan but i must say it was very unfair coz amanat got very low indian votes n the pakistani’s weren’t allowed to vote at the finals..

sorry to be rude but a step should be taken to this injustice act..

Reply to this comment
Aanshi on October 16th, 2007 1:31 pm

I will definitely try and upload them..

Reply to this comment
MusicBuff on October 15th, 2007 6:49 pm

Ignore “tere bin sanu soniya” in the previous post

Reply to this comment
MusicBuff on October 15th, 2007 5:49 pm

btw, I’d like the following additions to the collection.

Amanat-
Kadhi aa mil
Kuchh mere dil ne
Rasme ulfat
Pyaar hai ya sazaa
Sawan beeto jaaye
Hamein tumse pyaar
Tum jo mil gaye

Aneek-
Chand mera dil

Harpreet-
Rabba rabba mee
Tere bin sanu soniya
Nasha hi nasha
Main ramta jogi
Maye ri

Joy-
Aaja jane jaan
Alvida
HummaDil keh raha hai

Apurva-
Tadap tadap
Rimjhim gire
Dil mein baji guitar

Reply to this comment
MusicBuff on October 15th, 2007 4:44 pm

Aanshi/Admin,
Sorry to say this, but the MP3s suck! The quality is not good at all. Sound like the records played on a low voltage source

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 15th, 2007 2:50 pm

Aanshi,
Your idea of the show will work really good in radioâ€¦I guess. We can have some fake-names of the contestants and hear them singing and voteâ€¦.!!

Reply to this comment
sheetal1210 on October 15th, 2007 2:48 pm

now i m happy pease at forum
thank god
hey jenny dont feel sorry
u r dear frnd

Reply to this comment
Aanshi on October 15th, 2007 2:42 pm

Sheetal..

I have uploaded some songs of Harpreet.. Let me know if you want any song for any challenger.. I will try and upload that as well..

Reply to this comment
jennyash on October 15th, 2007 2:31 pm

sheetal sorry about today. yesterday at my house to much bashing regarding this situation

it was in my mind heart and everything.

sorry yaar to you my friend, to anshi and to sandip

hope u all will forgive me sorry

tnx

Reply to this comment
Aanshi on October 15th, 2007 2:30 pm

MusicBuff…

I didnt think of this.. yeah..

Lets just say.. contestants will be given unique number.. and thats the way to identify them.. how about that?

Actually I know it is a very bizzare thought.. and can never be implemented..

Reply to this comment
sheetal1210 on October 15th, 2007 2:28 pm

Sabhi Muslim Ko EID MUBARAK
HINDU KO “HAPPY NAVRATRI”

Reply to this comment
sheetal1210 on October 15th, 2007 2:28 pm

hey Anshi
there must be of Harpreet too
if u can upload it pls

Reply to this comment
sheetal1210 on October 15th, 2007 2:24 pm

yeah There is my jenny
now came back dear
i thought i lost u somewhere???
yeah thank god

Sheetal

Reply to this comment
sheetal1210 on October 15th, 2007 2:23 pm

Hey Anshi
i will definatly listen it…
Anshi I m feeling so sorry for you.
The generator of website is giving continuosly proofs for her honesty….
anyway dear I will listen of ur fav and my fav…Aneek and Amanat
and u knw whom i like 3rd and 4th
Mussart and Poonaam and 5th Areeey pau pau guy “Harpreet”

Aneek
Amanat
Mussarat
Poonam
Harpreet

and wil let u knw hw i found?
hey Anshi dont tak heart some comments from tis forum dear…pls

Sheetal

Reply to this comment
jennyash on October 15th, 2007 2:19 pm

i appologise anshi to drag you i was upset and so many people saying different things so i blasted

sorry anshi

mwaf kardena dost esa kabhi nahi hoga, pata nahi kya hogaya mujhay aaj.

eid mubarak aap ko

Reply to this comment
MusicBuff on October 15th, 2007 2:11 pm

Aanshi,
If we dont know anything about the contestant, how will we identify them and vote for them

Reply to this comment
Aanshi on October 15th, 2007 2:05 pm

Hey Sandip, Sheetal, Beingfair, Jenny, Shanai, Rajdeep..

Did you guys listen to the songs that I have uploaded on this site?

I just cant stop listening to some of the songs.. they are so good..

My favorite are Amanat’s Hungama, Tujhse Naraz Nahi, Yeh Hosla, Ajab Si OSO.. Raja’s Rut Aa Gai, Upar Khuda.. God there are so many.. never ending list..

I just had a very bizzare thought.. How about having a musical talent hunt show.. where we dont know anything about a contestant.. dont even get to see their face.. just listen to their performances and then decide via sending votes.. I think chances of most talented contestant getting selected will be much higher than what we get these days.. from these reality shows..

WHat do you guys think?

Reply to this comment
MusicBuff on October 15th, 2007 1:46 pm

@All,
What’s wrong with u guys? This forum is full of hatred, accusations and filth. What are all you guys fighting for? The contest is over. Stop sulking!! What are we going to achieve out of this?
I am a big Amanat fan, and wanted him to win. Having said that, Aneek is a very good singer as well, and so is Raja. They all have some strengths and some weaknesses.
I am so proud of Amanat after seeing how dignified he was when the results were announced. Why can’t we accept the results like that? Some of you have gone so overboard…just dont know how to put it!
A message to Aneek fans:
Why on earth are you trying to give explanation to everyone? If people are sulking, let them do so, and let them believe what they want to.

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 15th, 2007 1:43 pm

sharibhai,
After you sir!
Lead the way!!!!

Reply to this comment
sharibhai on October 15th, 2007 1:30 pm

to all aneek fans plz jus get a life and die

Reply to this comment
Aanshi on October 15th, 2007 1:21 pm

Beingfair..

Sorry.. but I didnt see any of your comments in moderation or spam folder..

Just try to re post it..

Reply to this comment
Aanshi on October 15th, 2007 1:16 pm

Hey Jenny..

its high time.. you have to understand this.. I have not fooled anyone here.. I am not biased at all.. If you have your favorite.. I too have my favorite.. and IT IS AMANAT… I have not hired people to promote Aneek and Amanat.. I dont know anyone personally in this forum.. all people in these forum have their own favorites. and are trying really hard to make their favorite look good..

I have not even done that anytime.. I have never commented that much to make Amanat look good.. or for the fact……… I have never pulled down any other contestant to make him look the best..

I just enjoy his performances.. and now listen to the songs he performed in Saregamapa..

Reply to this comment
jennyash on October 15th, 2007 1:11 pm

straight from ISMAIL DARBAR’S MOUTH

“The organisers have not played fair. The best singer was Amanat and Raja was the favourite. It’s obvious the votes were rigged.The counting process was not transparent. I am not happy with the results,” said Ismail Durbar.

WOW WOW HE SHOULD HAVE COME OUT CLEAN FROM BEGINNING.

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 15th, 2007 12:57 pm

ID sucks big time.
He said in an interview to Zee that Amanat should have won: â€œjisne bhi yeh SMS ka system banaya hai, bilkul bakwas hai! Third class hai!

Darbar Saâ€™ab I should remind you of your earlier declarations: â€œjunta jo bhi karegi, bilkul soch samajh kar karegiâ€?, and â€œjanta ka faisla sar aankhon parâ€??

I would also like to remind you that you have been complainging of vote rigging in SRGMP 2005 when your candidate Debojit was trailing Vineet and Himani in exactly the same way!
But when Debojit won you said” Janta bilkul soch samajh kar vote kia!!!”

Grapes are sour?

Reply to this comment
jennyash on October 15th, 2007 12:31 pm

HEY GUYS I FOUND THIS ARTICLE WHAT U ALL SAY

Wow wow… after the sizzling award ceremony and the total non sporting spirit shown by Himesh reshammiyya on the final stage on october 13 in front of 22,000 people… Ismail darbar the mentor of Amanat ali the singer from pakistan and a long time celebrity judge on saregamapa has finally opened his mouth….

As per a leading news challenge Ismail darbar thinks that there has been some sort of fixing / setup done in Aneek dhar’s win of the saregamapa 2007 challenge.. though the news channel did not associate any news footage or interview supporting this it appears that the controversy is taking fire like catch as far as voting is concerned… as far as the finals were concerned Aneek dhar who was leading the vote for some part of the show has emerged as a winner with less than 2 million votes … surprisingly the 100’s of thousands of votes really come from the SMS and telephone that generates lot of revenue for the service provides and the show hosts…

While Ismail darbar’s comments are been seen as a ignition to the reality show stunts… I think millions of ruppes been spent on the voting is something that surely needs to be reviewed…..while the win of Aneek shar is linked to a faulty voting system there are also un-confirmed rumours all over the internet world that Aneek dhar’s win has something to do with setup and supported voting’s…

What is true and what is not is a later part while Raja Hasan who had been heading the position seeems to be the most affected person due to all this.. Raja Hasan who had been leading the show almost for more than 50% of times been the highest number of vote reciever had to fall back with a million more votes just in the finals? Yes of course there is a question here… since aneek dhar though been a very god performer had not got such huge support as compared to amanat ali and Raja Hasan….

I am waiting to see Raja’s statement on this and Himesh’s reaction over the comments on the saregemapa final contreversy…..

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 15th, 2007 11:27 am

That’s what I was talking about. Look at the recent videos…they are best of friends and we are making all sorts of assumptions here…and spoiling our good times….!

Reply to this comment
jennyash on October 15th, 2007 11:27 am

sheetal
I am not like that at all let me tell you i am from east africa and i had my best friends who were hindu when we celebrate eid we are all together when they celebrate diwali we are all together and also i use to attend navratri dandiya’s and garbas no difference till today we are are best of friends never ever differenciatted. But seeing all this sgrmp just gave me some answers i was the one in this forum when people started attacking regarding hindu muslim i said first we all are human being than religion follows RELIGION IS MADE BY US HUMANS SO WE CAN PRAY TO GOD. As they say different streets but one avenues.

When i had guests at my house on saturday all they had to say was that muslims will never become better in india i don’t want to repeat the history but it just got into me

I am not like that sheetal never.

But than why were 2 muslims put down at least they should have given 1 of them a better crown
be it raja or amanat.

Sorry no hard feelings sheetal.

If this would have happen in muslim country i am sure u would have said of what i said.

tnx

Reply to this comment
sheetal1210 on October 15th, 2007 11:17 am

This frndship meant Aneek and amnat frndship which i just saw in newly posted videos

Reply to this comment
sheetal1210 on October 15th, 2007 11:16 am

This friendship shows everything. This says everything and gives all answers to jenny ur question. I am nt at al belive ur idea abt HINDU MUSLIM..why Atif, mustaffa, Adnaan sami, meera, and many more are surviving in india.because all liking them. Jenny try to understand dear..pls
And as a frnd i m telling u.
i m really hurt by tis issue..EID MUBARAK to you allâ€¦

I didnt like that Jenny Sorry
I can tolerate Aneekâ€™s defeat than tis really
bye

I m with nobody but i personnally hurt by tis hindu muslim difference comments
We indians hav always accepted good artists..and we all are human beings first.
UN said before that India is only country which never attacks before smbdy harrass it or distubrs it…This is biggest Example..
I proud to be India and i proud on Aneek too he made a pakistani a best frnd..Thats wht always a indian done and will continue to do…
Hey Anshi dont underestimate urself after all dirty comments dear i admire you as a good person..

bye

Reply to this comment
jennyash on October 15th, 2007 10:56 am

sandip your comment toward this
We have so many muslim celebrities in India that it will not be possible for you to count them! I donâ€™t see any non-muslim celebrity in any islamic country! So much so for being neutral.

Answer
In india the highest population is muslim ( by the way).And well indian movies are more popular than any other muslim countries. Now if in paksitan the First of all movies there were not allowed so certain people watched it never got popular in paksitan.

If in pakistan movies or singers were popular than i am sure pakistanis would have welcomed everybody.

In quran allah has said to treat equal to everybody.

However indian movies and songs are way way popular and Asper celebrities are muslims more than others than as i mentiones HIGHEST POPULATION IN INDIA IS MUSLIM.

get it sandipb

DHIRANI HUYU MTU ANATAKA KIBAO FROM ME

NITAMPIGA KWELI .

CIAO

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 15th, 2007 10:49 am

Thanks Dhirani and Beingfair!
I know I can always rely on you!

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 15th, 2007 10:46 am

Guys we all are here because we are music lovers. That’s why we are spending so much of time on this. WE don’t like to read comments such as who is party with whom. Please there should be a limit to what we write in the forum!!!

It’s a public forum and sounds very ugly when we make certain comments like this.

Let’s limit our discussion to the contestants and not extend it to others. We are least bothered who is with whom and we don’t even know each other except for those fake names…

Reply to this comment
Dhirani on October 15th, 2007 10:38 am

hey sandipq,

seems like you are getting emotional, please do not, as said before, the die hard fans cannot accept even a word agains their favourite and therefore jinny too cannot take this.

all in all, a few things you said is right and jinny is not totally wrong too.

i hope you understand when i say ‘die hard’ fan. let me give you an example:

i was in London in the early 80’s and ardent ‘cricket’ fan and i knew this cousin of ours, a ‘die hard’ fan who used to reside alone in harrow after her mother died (she was 40+ and a very mature person). so one day this distant cousing, after liaising with her had come for about 10/12 days to stay with her from Tanzania, at that time pakistan was playing england and her favourite cricketer was imran khan. however this cousin used to joke about imran, anyway when i took him out once i told her about her being the ‘die hard’, he still carried on and on the third day at around 11pm, she kicked her out of her place, why, just because she could not hear anything said against imran khan. so this is ‘die hard’ fan.

they will say anything, involve anything as they are quite unafraid on their favourites behalf.

do you agree???????????

Reply to this comment
jennyash on October 15th, 2007 10:27 am

sandipb
u never met anshi but u are defending her

Please i don’t want to read your long bhashan please excuse me for it.

COMMENT EDITED

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 15th, 2007 10:18 am

Jenny,
I never met Aanshi in my life so please don’t drag her name into it. You can say whatever you want to against me, I don’t mind.
From the day Raja was introduced in the competition Aanshi always mentioned Raja.
A few examples…
Raja Hasan star of yesterdayâ€™s episode today gave another mind blasting performance. He sang Tere Bin Nahi Lagda from the Movie Kacche Dhaage. All the mentors are really impressed by his singing.
Bikanerâ€™s Raja Hassan sang the high-register Sune le sathiya (Old Dus). Salman was so impressed by him that he started with: â€œAre you mad? Nobody sings so perfectly: You are already a singer, you do not have to be here.â€?Hearing this Vishal and Shekhar gave him a standing ovation
Raja Hasan sang Ishq Tere Ban Jaaye.. Raja took a pause for couple of seconds in the middle of the song.. Vishal said someone in the audience asked him to sing Allah Ke Bande and someone said once more for his todayâ€™s performance.. Vishal pointed out that as he remembered the Allah Ke Bande song really well.. he was able to sing it perfectly.. So he asked Raja to understand the lyrics and learn them properly before choosing and performing the song.. Good Advice Mr. Mentor..
Raja Hasan sings Rut Aa Gai Re from the movie Earth.. His favorite singer is Sukhvinder Singh.. It was a great performance..

Also one full article about Raja Hasan
So why is she not neutral?

I know you have visited Raja Hasan’s site quite a few times since you have posted some comments from there. Tell me, are they neutral? Have they said one single good thing, and I repeat, one single good thing about any of the contestants?
Did you protest then? I did but my comments were delted!

So much so for your neutral attitude!
Let me tell you one thing very bluntly. We have so many muslim celebrities in India that it will not be possible for you to count them! I don’t see any non-muslim celebrity in any islamic country! So much so for being neutral.
I learned Sarod for 14 years under Ustad Amjad Ali Khan ( a muslim but married to a hindu girl of Calcutta).
I performed a few times accompanied on the tabla by Pranesh Khan ( son of Ali Akbar Khan) and a childhood friend of mine since kindergarden days!
I don’t differntiate anybody.
Anyway, no point writing this!

PS: Amanat is still my favourite!!!

Reply to this comment
piya on October 15th, 2007 10:15 am

JENNY,
i am not satisfied abt wat u said that india can never let a muslim singer win.
couldn’t u notice the COLD RESPONSE of audience(including hindus also) sitting in the auditorium at the ewe of grand finale N as aneek was anounced to be a winner,audience left out within few sec.
on last friday,i organised one survey in my college(D.U.)(n it was the part of entertainment section) in which i asked my collegues “who should be the winner of this contest”
in that abt 80% votes were for RAJA
15% for amanat
only 5% for aneek n i was literally shocked after seeing the final results.

KOI TO HIMESH KE AGAINST FATWA JAARI KARE .
GOD WILL DEFINETELY PUNISH HIM BECZ
HE HAD BROKEN THE HEART OF PIOUS SOUL HUMAN BEING “RAJA”.

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 15th, 2007 10:05 am

Hey Jenny…that “ok fine” was not for u but for the admin…as I got frustrated that I couldn’t write something I wanted to.

I will say it from the core of my heart that yes “amanat you are awesome”

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 15th, 2007 10:00 am

Ok fine! I wanted to post a neutral comment…and somehow it’s not being posted
Anyways guys don’t think I was about to pick a fight with anyone.
I like all of you …Shanai. Jenny, Dhirani, Sheetal, Music-fan, music-buff, Indecent, Sandip aanshi….

Reply to this comment
jennyash on October 15th, 2007 9:59 am

beingfair, I agree with you but i just cannot put behind when wrong thing has happened. honestly amanat should have won.

And i don’t beleive in these votes either they were created just to make aneek win

firstly intenational votes amanat was ahead
indian votes Raja was ahead

So where did aneek get all the highest votes

scammers.

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 15th, 2007 9:54 am

I don’t understand whta’s the problem they don’t want me to say something which really makes sense…I simply am unable to post this comment here!! what’s wrong!….

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 15th, 2007 9:52 am

admin please don’t truncate my comment I am not writing anything filthy

If the difference in total vote doesn’t reach a singificant of level probability

Reply to this comment
jennyash on October 15th, 2007 9:51 am

hey shanai
this comment of yours :IT was someone elseâ€™s and GIVEN to YOU because you are HINDU. ( THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT MY HUSBAND SAID). They wanted to slap muslims on the eid day.

hey i agree aneek should have been in little champ bast…

I just wanna see how far he goes . They played a good game but god knows the rest.

By winning the title aneek is much less popular than raja and amanat.

All the talks of the town is raja and amanat.

They had guts and have guts to pullthemselves through from the beginning of the competition.

hatts of to them.

sandipb
u said keep anshi out of this but anshi is the one who wrote this.
U were always commenting thats all?

open your eyes before u defend my dear.

Anshi i always thought as a good person and still beleive that and so do u sandip i think u r good too but fooling people is not good

there is parmatma watching all this.

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 15th, 2007 9:46 am

Comeon guys forget about who got the first position and let’s be friends. They all rock! Amanat definately needs a very special recognition for his talent.

Technically speaking…..

In research an investigator does not consider a difference between two numbers as a difference as long as the difference doesn’t reach statistical significance at P

Reply to this comment
jennyash on October 15th, 2007 9:37 am

SHANDIPB it wasn’t for u at that time today when i see all i felt that and i said what my heart said. Truthful i am very i believe in god first of all and i am to much believer so i didn’t lie than either.

This forum was aneek and amanat Am i correct.

I did pinpoint anshi that why he /she doesn’t write good about raja, but still i came and fought for him.

Dhirani,
eid mubarak.

Think why mussarat had to go ?.

And himesh’s image is so down that i don’t think people will waste their maoney to watch his upcoming movies.

I don’t hate no one. So i will not write any hate e-mails what i said was my feelings.

So how did u know my votes towards raja?

Thats what i feel

Always the cheers here were aneek and amanat.

Anything i wrote about raja u guys ignored so isnt this politics.

hey what goes around comes around .

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 15th, 2007 9:29 am

Jeeny Good to see you, I had reply this. for all, specialy Aneek Lovers what you done for him, basically scrued HIM and his growing life.

Finally truth prevailed and Sorry for you

LITTLE ANEEK

ANEEK hey Little Champ, Oops! You won the wrong title.

ANEEK you are very YOUNG. All of your life still to GO and your carrier just started with a FAKE, False, manipulated and biased. They fooled you at your early life. This realy BAD for your rest of the life.

Moving Forward â€œ PLEASE REJECT THIS CROWN for your well beingâ€œ
Mere bhai tere future ke liye pls REJECT the TILTE.
BE a brave BOY who starts with Truth.

AS this was setup and you are a NOT a TRUE winner.

IT was someone elseâ€™s and GIVEN to YOU because you are HINDU.

ITS not a talent Show but money making Show.

THEY MADE FUN OF YOU. Sorry Bengali fan. This is TRUE what I am saying.

Jai Himesh. No one left to beat u MAN. Aneek is real poor singer as to be your competitor. SO, HR smart and Indian music MARKET remains yours. If raja were there; might make your life HELLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLlllllllllll.

Reply to this comment
Dhirani on October 15th, 2007 9:24 am

Hey Gujju gang and the rest,

First of all, I appreciated the comments by all the die hard fans, the moderate and the neutral fans, all expressed their inner feelings without any physical repercussion. I think these type of forum / blogs are good to express your feelings, I hope you all agree.

Anyways:

The results are out and Aneek is the winner. All the fans have a different verdict, however, I must at this point make one thing very very clear.

Aneek, Amanat or Raja, all were good and the one with the most loyal and money spending FANS won the competition, therefore if your favourite has not won the competition its only yourself to be blamed.

Today this site has launched the songs of all the participants and I am happy to say that you will not go looking for your favourite only as the songs sung by aneek, raja and amanat all are EQUALLY good and hearable, just because raja is not as versatile or aneeks voice is a bit boyish does not give a license to amanat for winning this race.

I do not blame anyone, my favourite was Mussarat and after that I choose to proceed with Amanat.

However, I do not regret the result.

Best of luck to all the 10 finalist in their future. FYI presently after Mauli, Junaid is the busiest artist.

and as HR says God Bless all.

N.B.
I watched AAP KA SAROOR and let me tell you, it suâ€”â€“ big time. HR is not capable to become an actor, just a singer is fine for him.

These are 100% my feelings and its okay to differ.

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 15th, 2007 9:20 am

Thank you Jennyash!
I am now seriously considering your advice of joining politics!
When I told Sheetal that your accusation was against me you said that no it was not!
Does that make you a truthful person ?
Please do not drag Aanshi’s name into this dirt game!

If you want to send me hate mails in the same volume as you voted for Raja please do it at the following address…
sandiphome@yahoo.com
Not on this public forum.

PS: Amanat is still my favourite!!!

Reply to this comment
jennyash on October 15th, 2007 9:01 am

Beingfair
Thanks but a lot of people will not agree regarding the situation saregamapa has put it.

1)IT WAS CALLED INTERNATIONAL BUT HOW COULD IT BE ( NO SPANIOL NO FRANCOIS NO GREEK

They were sgrmp pakistani and indians this was between these 2 countries.

Sorry my friend Aneek can’t digest.

I would say amanat should have won.

I luv raja but i can’t stand chipmunk.
ok he won and i know aneeks friend must be happy but we will see further whats happening.

Sandipb kept saying his fav was amanat lies freaking cheat always aneek as he sue to say i am from calcutta

well played politician.

u both should be in politics .

consider it.

adios

Reply to this comment
sheetal1210 on October 15th, 2007 8:37 am

Thank you Anshi for this website and thanks to ur hubby too..
Thnaks to Jenny(my frnd), Sandipd, Sonali, Joel,The incedent, music fan, sandeep, Dhirani,,hitsquad(lost), and sorry if forgetting smbdy…ir was great time wth u guys..
leaving forum but wil be back by litl champ
hope we will all hav the sam egroup and same choice…
hey Jenny be in touch dear
bye all

To my little wonder —Hatts off congrats
Amanat—Best singer
Raja—good singer but need to be versatile like Amanat and Aneek..

hey i wish all the best allthree
Aneek dont stop working hard God bless u all three
bye tc
Sheetal

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 15th, 2007 8:04 am

Hi Jenny,

If I was at your place probably I would have felt equally sad. I do understand your feelings.

But one thing is for sure that Indians are much more broadminded compared to many other countries of the world. Moreover in the music industry I thnik it’s a absolutely wrong belief that Indians discriminate in terms of music.I think there more muslims than Hindus in Bollywood who are most popular.

Did you see the difference of votes between Raja and Aneek - few thousands.
I would have said that indians are discriminative if there was a significant difference in the total number of votes earned bewteen the two.

I think we should think that all three are the winners. If you see their videos u’ll be surprised to see how friendly they are..and we are making all sorts of assuptions here.

I’ll again say that I do understand your feelings after all we all are humans with emotions.

Reply to this comment
jennyash on October 15th, 2007 7:06 am

Let me say something you all feel bad to bad. but my point in India no muslim singer will win.

When saregamapa little Champs Sameer(MUSLIM) was third.

Than the program where there was ujaini and who the hell other was don’t care won and Shahrukh (MUSLIM) No 2.

India can never let muslim win sorry to say that.

For Aneek watu izzu mantu shah and watu zillu mantu shah. (ismail darbar had said this and i am repeating this).

Today aneek is with izzat let time go and will see how much far he goes

To me Aneek is a thief comes in the middle and win the fu…

This was all set up.

To me raja is the winner

Jsut at the end of the program some people were so shocked

Sorry i am shifting my gears and outa here

AS MY HUSBAND SAID THIS IS IT JENNY NO MORE.

AS i knew this site was for mostly Aneek and Amanat but i fought for the right man raja

Reply to this comment
sharibhai on October 15th, 2007 4:05 am

to rambo stop toking crap and every1 wont hate u

Reply to this comment
shaz on October 14th, 2007 5:43 pm

fireheart007 i totally agree. and evry body on this forum i love u…

and amanat is the best

Reply to this comment
RAMBO on October 14th, 2007 12:54 pm

Hi everyone. I am not from India or Pakistan but from a small island in the South Pacific. I love Indian songs whether its Ghazals from Pakistan or India or from Adnan Sami Khan from Toronto. My point is that all these 3 singers (Aneek, Amanat and Raja) are winners in most peopleâ€™s heart.
In last contestant, Avinnet sang very well but Debu became a winner. As for my self, I had a hunch that Debu will win because he can sing easily without much effort. Same thing I noticed with Aneek. If one listens properly and concentrate then u will find that Aneek has a wonderful sweet voice and modulating very well from high peech to low peech. This doesnâ€™t mean that other singers are bad even most of them were also very good but somehow were out of the race because of judges or votes.
I donâ€™t know Bengali language so it doesnâ€™t matter whether Aneek knows Hindi or not but he sings well. Some of us donâ€™t realized that Bengali are very good in music and singing thats why we had music directors like SD & RD burman, Sali Choudhary and singers like Dwijen Mukherji, Kishore and Amit Kumar, Kumar Sanu, Babul Supriyo and Abhijeet to name a few.
About Himesh and new music directors, I personally donâ€™t like much as they donâ€™t give hits like old songs from old music directors. Perhaps the trend has changed and younger generations got used to it by listening these types of Rap songs. When looking at profiles of Himesh R, Shekhar-Vishal and Ismail Darbar, I was amazed that somehow HR Ãs more successful from others by giving more hits and music for movies.
Sometimes I canâ€™t understand why producers are not assigning good music directors like Nadeem-Sharvan, Bappi Lahiri, Jatin Lalit, etc whose songs are melodious than noisy, high peech songs from HR, SV, etc.
Anyway Indians (especially majority of Hindus) donâ€™t go by caste system and for that reasons we have so many muslim artist in top positions like Mohammad Rafi, Dilip Kumar (Yusuf Khan), Amir Khan, Salman Khan, Sharukh Khan, Saif Ali Khan, Meena kumari, Suraiya, Madhubala, Feroze Khan, etc, etc.
So its not a matter of religion that Amanat and Raja lost. India has more Hindus. Pakistan and overseas have more muslim countries, so we shouldnâ€™t think on religious line but should think as who is good at singing without much effort and had a very good voice with right tune and to me that is Aneek.
I believe Zee TV went to other cities like Delhi,etc to look for new talanted singers and somehow they missed Aneek who has won in some contest and was worthy of entry in Saregamapa.
Well Zee TV got him in for contest and we all should be happy to have him so in future we can listen to some good songs with sweet voice like Rafi, Kishore, Sanu, Udit, Abhjeet and Sonu.
Congratulations to Aneek, Amanat and Raja

Reply to this comment
sharibhai on October 14th, 2007 12:42 pm

to amit plz stop talking bul u know amanat is the best.

Reply to this comment
sharibhai on October 14th, 2007 12:37 pm

to man plz stop toking crap i beg u amanat is the best so face it

Reply to this comment
sharibhai on October 14th, 2007 12:31 pm

watevr indecent go to hell

Reply to this comment
amitavaindia on October 14th, 2007 12:10 pm

Begali Commnity and Saregamapa competion has a one to one connection.. There was no way for any other champ.. It was Aneek’s dediation, hardworking and ***. Dont feel jelus.. ANEEK will ROCK the world for next 25 years..

most of the internet user were against ANEEK. Most of you were for RAJA’s favour. then how ANEEK cross the international voting than RAJA? yey RAZZ ki bat hai..

Iske piche a Bengali ki hatt hai.. He is also from Kolkata (A computer enginer)… i do not want to disclose his name…

…………..CHAK DE BENGALI…………….

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 14th, 2007 11:38 am

Best non-indian member of this forum:

Murtaza Rana

My heartiest thanks for being so civilized !

Reply to this comment
TheIndecent on October 14th, 2007 11:17 am

First of All Thanx to All Indians who have been voted for Amanat.

Secnondly Congrats to all Aneek Fans. You People Made It.

Third: Congrats to Sheetal, Beingfair, Rajdeep and all the die hard fans of Aneek, who made this true.

I really Appreciate Sandip and Beingfair comments and would like to salute to you people as you are still neutral.

I really would like to Thanx Anshi, for writing live updates for us.

Best Moderator: Anshi
Best Posts : Sandip / Beingfari / Sheetal / Jennyash / Dhirani.

Finally i would to request all the Amanat and Raja Fans to praise for Aneek as well. The Show is over,winner has been declared and we have to face the reality. Its all the part of our life. Its not always possible that what you desire, you will get. Show the true spirit of Music and Congrats Aneek for Winning.

Murtaza Rana
KSA

Reply to this comment
fireheart007 on October 14th, 2007 11:15 am

well my brother .. its you who is frustrated at the truth and it is showing in your message.. lol
just blindly screaming aneek aneek aneek… why didnt u reply to the FACTS that i have written in my loooonnngggg post… huh? i am not saying aneek is bad.. he is pretty good…BUT didnt deserve to win!!
and as far as bollywood success in concerned .. wait for 4 more years for that my dear friend whereas our other finalists have ALREADY put their put in the bollywood door!! hehe… see man .. i dont hate aneek .. but be practical…. and see the reasons i gave….

Reply to this comment
sunnydg on October 14th, 2007 10:54 am

WELL DEAR BROTHER ALL WHAT YOU HAVE WRITTEN SIMPLY SHOWS YOUR BIASNESS !!
WHATEVER YOU ALL FANATIC ANTI-BONG AND ANTI-HR PEOPLE KEEP SAYING, YOU CAN NOT DIFFER THE TRUTH THAT THE ROYAL CUP OF BENGAL, THE RED BENGAL BLOOD THE BENGAL PRIDE, THE BENGAL TIGER…MY ANEEK DHAR OUR ANEEK DHAR HAS DEFEATED ALL THE ODDS AND BIASED CRITICISM LIKE U ALL AND HAS AT LAT EMERGED AS THE WINNER.
NOW TIME WILL TELL WHO ROCKS THE BOLLYWOOD IN THE TIME TO COME…..TILL THEN HAPPY FRUSTRATION !!

Reply to this comment
fireheart007 on October 14th, 2007 10:40 am

hi guys
congrats to aneek
however theres a lot of debate about why he won
its true its coz of HR and his cheap publicity stunts … also he wanted revenge for vinit… also he talks a load of crap.. you guys saw how aditya shut him up when he was talking crap after aneek winning .. he just talked over him and HR had to shut up .. lol
ok back aneek. he was good but he has a kids voice thats why he didnt get any offers from bolywood yet when compared to other 2 guys and also sumedha….. and someone rote about international votes rite?.. did u notice one thing ..in the interview after the show amanats dad said voting from pakistan was not possible for technical reasons!!!!! what the hell??? does anyone know abot this?? then its a disgrace…. they say its a worldcup of singers and no voting from pak. if indians can get votes from indians and why not paki from pakistan???this is biased. and if you guys say its purely indian show as its being held and produced in india then why promote it as world cup and have voting from middleeast????.. amanat was super and he couldnt win as he would always be last in indian votes. raja should have won….. but o well…. just notice how everyone starts talking after the show ends… amnanats dad said there is no voting from pakistan after the show ended .. but he also said it doesnt matter and everything is fair in love and war..no prob.. very good and also the love that amanat got in india is truly amazing… salute all indians for that …. so that was one interview. did u guys see ismail darbar interview after show !! lol…
he just took out all his anger there… so said he wanted HR to win anyway .. how crazy… and said that people who win these talent contests with public votes end up nowhere .. very true to most extent…. and then he said aneek still has 4 YEARS BEFORE HE GETS PLAYBACK VOICE … lol.. how funny pppl start saying things after show is over… why didnt he ever say this during the show that he had a kids voice and couldnt be dunya a voice NOW…. i agree he is good but shouldnt have won. then also he said that he wont accept anyone coming in between the show and saying i was winner in another small how so take me in between as aneek said. so he didnt accept aneek coming in between the competition anyway from the beginning. its true .. he compared with Aussies in criket.. just because they are triple world camps doesnt mean they get direct entry to semi finals of the next world cup…. they have to play from beginning…. so see there are soo many things about aneek winning…. but i hate HR for promoting such a good singer so cheaply to make himself win and take revenge for vinit… and ismail knew that but didnt say much… anyway .. thats my analysis… its a bilong but pls read and reply!!:)

Reply to this comment
ALTAF74 on October 14th, 2007 10:39 am

Amanat you are the BEST OF BEST. No matter what was the result but here in USA everybody, i mean everybody believe from all the honesty that neither Aneek nor Raja was even closer to you. You literally rocked the show with your outstanding performances. I can bet that even people in India know that they did wrong but its ok. Your work will speak in future and i strongly believe this. Your performances like Mahiway and that song from Masoom was superb. Aneek and Raja can never sing like you did throughout the show and as Diya Mirza said its going to be unjustice with you if you dont get votes from India because she knew that you deserve 1st position and even she knew that Indian people will not vote fairly, but as i said it does’nt even matter. You are the Best and heart’s voice is more stronger than the votes and people all over the world knew in their heart that NO ONE WAS BETTER THAN YOU. So chill and focus on your future. I truly pray for your success and i am sure that you will get more work even in India more than Aneek and Raja. I knew the result but i am still happy cuz Aneek was surely better than Raja. In last few episodes Raja was trying to be more like Hero than a Singer. Hamesh BS will never gonna stop and he play games verbally and emotionally just to make his Gharana a winner.

Reply to this comment
Sandy on October 14th, 2007 10:05 am

I like Junaid, Sumedha and Aneek… and Junaid among all.. Aneek is also a good singer but I also agree that Himesh shouldn’t create fake stories just to make his contestant win. Since HR created fake stories and linked Aneek with most of the female guests on the show, today people are forced to think that Aneek just won cos of all fake stories and this is a bad remark for Aneek’s victory. Though I liked Junaid a lot, I believe that Aneek deserves to be a winner cos he has a great voice and the way he sings those English lines in some songs are great… And reason for Sumedha to be out was again HR. He kept on telling about Poonam’s mom in every episode and she got sympathy votes and cos of that Sumedha was out… Then when Musharath was out he shouted telling Raja gets sympathy votes which sounded really foolish cos Musharat was singing same kind of songs everytime and that was the reason for him to be out. Among the mentors I like Vishal and Shekar… and especially Vishal… Just cos of HR, people should’t think that Aneek doesn’t deserve his victory… Aneek deserves to be a winner… And I’m really waiting for Junaid’s album to be released by Vishal & Shekar…

Reply to this comment
vote4indian on October 14th, 2007 9:53 am

JO JEETA WOHI SIKANDAR

ANEEK you were the best YOU ARE THE BEST AND YOU WILL B the best :ange:angel:l: :angel:

CONGRATS ANEEK N HIMESH

Reply to this comment
vote4indian on October 14th, 2007 9:52 am

JO JEETA WOHI SIKANDAR

ANEEK you were the best YOU ARE THE BEST AND YOU WILL B the best :ange:angel:l: :angel:

CONGRATS ANEEK N HIMESH

I KNW SOME PPL NEVER ACCEPT THE TRUTH ,,,N NEVER SEE ANYONE TO GET SUCCEED,,, ,,SO JUS CHIILLL OUT. :clown: :clown: ..COZâ€¦.ANEEK IS THE BEST SINGERâ€¦.AS V ALL KNWâ€¦. :party: :party: :party:

Reply to this comment
sg2007 on October 14th, 2007 7:37 am

In any case with the crappy music being dished out in Hindi Cinema these days, it doesnt make a difference about the skills of the playback singers…

Reply to this comment
sg2007 on October 14th, 2007 7:33 am

Hi,

Personally on the form in the last 3-4 episodes we should have had Amanat, Aneek, MUSSARAT & POONAM in the last 4. However, both the last two didnt have ‘it’ to please the Junta though both seem to be more accomplishes singers than Raja

Please dont misjudge my comments; Raja can beat anyone on his day, but dont know what it is, exhaustion or getting carried away by dancing,fame etc, Raja was definitely performing below par as the competition reached the final weeks.

The same cannot be said about my favourite four, who were performing well - CONSISTENTLY.

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 14th, 2007 7:24 am

Naini Naini Poo poo!Naini Naini Poo poo!Naini Naini Poo poo!

Reply to this comment
manbhat666 on October 14th, 2007 7:07 am

looser

Reply to this comment
kurtcobain on October 14th, 2007 7:03 am

oye machikne haru ho lado machikne….whatever u all say Amanat was the best Singer in saregama from the begining………what a vocal he have got really i am blessed to hear such a voice………i have only heard few people with that kina of voice…..he will be the best singer in pakistan and in india…….so what if he haven’t won saregama……actually he was never meant to win it cuz there was always HR there…….i think before the last couple of episode he publicised only aneek too much and really neglected the perpormance of Amanat and raja…….actually HR was jealous of Amanat one can see it in his eyes when Jagjit singh said you are the best singer of saregama……

Reply to this comment
iqbalsh on October 14th, 2007 6:47 am

The final voting was fixed no doubt, how considerate of them to make it look so close ie Amanat 34m plus votes, Raja 35m plus votes and Aneek 36m plus votes.

Who are they trying to kid exactly?

The thing that stood out was when the 2nd runner up was about to be announced the camera was fixed on Amanat’s mum (who was in the audience). It seems even the cameraman knew who got how many votes.

Zee tv if you’re going to organise an international contest then at least try to look beyond your own nationalistic emotions and give a fair chance to ALL contenders. Right throughout this challenge you have failed to do this.

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 14th, 2007 6:46 am

Hey sandipb, saw ur comments just now. Sorry man I left immediately. You guys did a good job of fighting back …! I am sure we all have become expert fighter cocks in last few months….

Reply to this comment
ghazi on October 14th, 2007 6:38 am

Again i repeat I give hats off to indian janta to give so much support to amanat… unbelievable

for the competition, as we all know it is bussiness, it is more of the money marketing, than it is talent hunt. If it was purely talent, that the judges would be real judges, and not janta, janta is only involved because of the trp of the show, and commercial/adv all the halla gulla, and this kind of argument, and all this drama. so when it comes to janta, ofcource there is always a national spirit or religoius spirit comes into play, and there is nothing wrong with that, like last time asaam ka debojit. It was all about asaam ka votes. in reality talent hunt, there are no boundaries, and no religion, it is one human being with the talent.

so when the voting is left by janta, ofcource somewhat thier national spirit has to kick in at the end, and again there is nothing wrong with that. it is perfectly normal and in my opinion is the good thing. we have to accept that amanat is number 3 out of all those people, is still indian and international people voting.

but again after amanat is set and done, raja didnt pull if off, is really amazing.

I personally dont think aneek had that much fan following than raja did from janta, that is why I think it was all set up.

Reply to this comment
manbhat666 on October 14th, 2007 6:24 am

many of you guys claim Amanat is the real winner if you consider only overseas votes. But in that case you should exclude Pakistan and Dubai also. If you do so again Aneek is the real winner. He stolen many of the episode in this contest compared to Amanat. Only in last 2 or three episode Amanat came better than Aneek.
So accept the fact. Aneek is the real winner

Reply to this comment
sharibhai on October 14th, 2007 5:54 am

to ghazi all i wud lik2say is that india has reali disgraced itself wid its voting and if this continues no1 from overseas wil participate im sowi

Reply to this comment
sharibhai on October 14th, 2007 5:47 am

i know what u mean shaz but ppl from india are narrow minded and cos of this i dont tink any1 will want2participate in an indian competition all over again

Reply to this comment
ghazi on October 14th, 2007 5:45 am

ok enuff reading,

I am pakistani by birth, by nature everything, but let me frist salute indian janta to give so much support that i never though it would be given. SALUTE TO THEM.

as far as the competition goes, YET everyone on this forum or any other forum you take it, like sara******show.com
the poll shows that it could be between amanat and raja, on thier poll they were running equal, and thier poll was way high if i recall it was 170 thosand on each participant, total votes were close to 400 thosand. so I could have never though that aneek will pull this off.

If raza would have won, I could understand, but aneek I dont think i can ever absorb that, but oh well it is over.

But I personally think that votes were temepered with, those werent the real votes, I dont think aneek touch millions heart like raja and amanat did. and by knowing HR everything is possible, he can do those stupid things

as far as grand finale is concern, I though it was boring as hell, long shows wanst carried all the weight and audience. I like the regular show much better than this grand finale, I think most of you will agree with me. The show was just plain, with no entertaiment. I think it wasnt properly orginized by ZEE, no tracks, no rythem,
one was coming and other was going, could keep up what was going on.

about HR, I think aditya was intructed by ZEE to cut his conversations short, and keep him away after aneek wins, he cut his conversations plenty of time during and show, and at the end as well, has any one notice?

Reply to this comment
shaz on October 14th, 2007 5:36 am

i cant help it sharabhai. I read every ones views and they give the wrong facts. for example some one said only jagjit singh said to amanat your the best and pandit ji didn’t but that is a lie. And someone said india voted more for amanat then pakistan but then i had to tell the pple that pakistan was not allowed to vote 4 the finals… I JUST DONT LIKE IT WHEN PPLE HAVE THERE FACTS WRONG

Reply to this comment
sharibhai on October 14th, 2007 5:32 am

to shaz i jsu want2say y do u even bother wen the ppl in the forum hav wax in their ears and not realise their mistakes.they hav dun an injustice to amanat any1 wid perferct musical sense can realise that amanat is the best and shall always be the best.

Reply to this comment
sharibhai on October 14th, 2007 5:27 am

i wud jus like tosay2aanshi plz stop actin innocent as evry1 knows ur da reason why aneek won i totall hate u.anyways to amanat fans what can we do if the indian public is biased.

Reply to this comment
shaz on October 14th, 2007 4:54 am

point 1. amanat did not get much votes as much as he could of gained due to pakistanis were not allowed to vote in the final.

point 2. pandit jasraj ji did say to amanat that in my books your number 1 and then jagjit singh ji said that you far better then the competition

point 3. aneeks voice is like sonu nigams and sonu is much better so thats why aneek is not gonna do well, he will fade away..mark my words.

point 4. amanat is the best

Reply to this comment
shaz on October 14th, 2007 4:51 am

point 1. amanat did not vote because pakistanis were not allowed to vote in the final.

point 2. pandit jasraj ji did say to amanat that in my books your number 1 and then jagjit singh ji said that you far better then the competition

point 3. aneeks voice is like sonu nigams and sonu is much better so thats why aneek is not gonna do well, he will fade away..mark my words.

point 4. amanat is the best

Reply to this comment
swie on October 14th, 2007 1:26 am

i feel that amanat is the true winner here..he deserved to be the first but he loss because of the low indian votes..so ya..

no doubt that aneek n raja r great singers but amanat was the best..is the best..n will always remain the best

all i can say is amanat came to india as a winner of saregamapa middle east n will go back as a winner..

conclusion is amanat is the actual winner n i pray he goes very far in life!!!!

Reply to this comment
sandeep on October 14th, 2007 1:14 am

Aneek’s interviews were real cool - not diplomatic at all. The party goes on…

And here is a titbit from how Zee is raking in the moolah. All the multiple SMS is pouring into the Zee coffers

This apart, Zee TV will earn an additional Rs 5 crore from SMS and tele-voting. The channel has partnered with telecom service providers to facilitate voting. The sources said that 40 per cent of this money goes to Zee TV, while the rest is retained by the service providers.

Reply to this comment
kira on October 13th, 2007 11:26 pm

hey galactilo who says aneek will never be a successful singer???come on aneek has won because his has obtained the most votes,this mean that the public finf his voice suitable for the music industry!and just wait and watch!he’ll rock everybody

Reply to this comment
Siddharth on October 13th, 2007 11:09 pm

Raja fans - you are losers. You are blaming the Aneek fans for what? You made Aneek the champion by not voting Raja. So, stop crying here. You knew, everyone knew that this is a vote game and if you think Raja is the best, make him best and that is your duty. If you could not, that’s your problem. If someone to blame, it’s you and not Zee TV, HR or Aneek or someone likes Aneek’s voice. Rajdeep said it correctly that you should have voted for Raja when you were writing some crap about Aneek or HR. You wasted your time and now, you are blaming like a loser. Aneek fans, loved him by heart, they knew what to do. They made him the champ. Now, now one knows if he will be successful or not. That is not a business here. Some of them can make it like Shreya, Kunal, Nihira, Antara Mitra (Last year’s Indian Idol - first among the girls). Some of them will not.
I am sure Amanat will surely make it. We will definitely see him singing for leading stars in Bollywood. And, he does not need support from guys like you. So is for Musarrat. Both of them are awesome singers and they deserve to alive in this industry.

But, Raja fans, if you can, please pray for Raja and make him successful. at least you can do it now. he needs your help. Don’t just blame on a religion or a community. Aneek made it for his fans. Thats end of the story. I wish him all success in his life. Sorry Raja fans if I hurt your feelings. I just got bit emotional by reading your unfair comments about Aneek. He is an 18 years boy. Instead of encouraging him, you are just making fun of him, hooting against him as if he does not know a b c of music. And, now when he has won, I am seeing people are more aggressive because of frustration. What is this?

Reply to this comment
kira on October 13th, 2007 11:07 pm

yes eventually the best is always rewarded!aneek has always been the best singer and surely he has a bright futur he will be the the king of the music industry sooner or later!!!!!!!!congrats!!!

Reply to this comment
shuvo on October 13th, 2007 11:06 pm

when 100/1000 million votes are counted at the end of the day, we can never say who was the deserving one.

in the web pole there are only 3k/4k people. during the final, at that spot, only 20k are present. and in this site, there are maximum of 1k people.

this total is not even 1% of the total votes.

peace.

Reply to this comment
its_me on October 13th, 2007 10:35 pm

who says that the fact that aneek won is not accepted we accept it with great respect but its also true that no one can also deny this fact that he was not as deserving as amanat or may be raja so friends lets accept that aneek is the winner of saregamapa allthough not being the best .

Reply to this comment
Siddharth on October 13th, 2007 10:31 pm

Raja fans - you are losers. You are blaming the Aneek fans for what? You made Aneek the champion by not voting Raja. So, stop crying here. You knew, everyone knew that this is a vote game and if you think Raja is the best, make him best and that is your duty. If you could not, that’s your problem. If someone to blame, it’s you and not Zee TV, HR or Aneek or someone likes Aneek’s voice.

Rajdeep said it correctly that you should have voted for Raja when you were writing some crap about Aneek or HR. You wasted your time and now, you are blaming like a loser.

Aneek fans, loved him by heart, they knew what to do. They made him the champ. Now, now one knows if he will be successful or not. That is not a business here. Some of them can make it like Shreya, Kunal, Nihira, Antara Mitra (Last year’s Indian Idol - first among the girls). Some of them will not.

I am sure Amanat will surely make it. We will definitely see him singing for leading stars in Bollywood. And, he does not need support from guys like you. So is for Musarrat. Both of them are awesome singers and they deserve to alive in this industry.

But, Raja fans, if you can, please pray for Raja and make him successful. at least you can do it now. he needs your help. Don’t just blame on a religion or a community.

Aneek made it for his fans. Thats end of the story. I wish him all success in his life.

Sorry Raja fans if I hurt your feelings. I just got bit emotional by reading your unfair comments about Aneek. He is an 18 years boy. Instead of encouraging him, you are just making fun of him, hooting against him as if he does not know a b c of music. And, now when he has won, I am seeing people are more aggressive because of frustration. What is this?

Reply to this comment
its_me on October 13th, 2007 10:29 pm

ok fine u r right if u think he has to go through such a tough competion but giving a chance to sumone bcoz he just won a regional show doesnt make a sense whoever may say anything the fact remains the same the reality shows cont their trend of making a real loser a winner

Reply to this comment
shuvo on October 13th, 2007 10:16 pm

some people are so poor in mind, they can never accept the wiiner. all those three contestants’ vote difference is very close. why you can’t appreciate raja and amanat also got near 350 million votes.

one thing is sure, amanat has got more votes in the final from india than any other region. so, please don’t say indians are biased. biased people are there in every region of the the world. but most of the world’s population is unbiased.

some are going offtrack and talking about religion and races. i am sure about 1 thing, among those 700 million votes raja & amanat got, there are many hindus, many bangalis and also many people from both india and pakistan. and the same goes to aneek also.

if u can’t accept the results, then there should be no democracy.

those people, who says zee has done something bad with the original results, do they have any proofe.

again, it was allowed to vote as many times as anyone wanted. so its also rediculous to say, this comunity does bad thing giving so many votes.

and aneek is very young. thats true. but this issue was never raised before jagjit shing had said these.

to those who said, aneek came at the middle. don’t you think, he had to pass the toughest exam before coming at the middle? he has to won a regional contest where sms voting doesn’t mean everything. there judges voting matters most. and i can tell you one thing, the judges of saregamapa bangla are much much better than the five judges of this years saregamapa challenge.

please, respect others opinions. all 3 are very good. and all of them will do excellent in future.

looking to anshi, sandipb and other sensible people.

i know, i’m going to get some hate mails now.

thanks everyone. sorry for such a long message.

Reply to this comment
its_me on October 13th, 2007 10:04 pm

watever anyone says amanat is the best n will always remain in our heart. n by the way the trend of all reality shows continued to make the worst winner n the best as a finalist this in itself proves that amanat is the winner

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 13th, 2007 9:51 pm

Yeeeeeeeep!!
You are right! Where you guys have been?
I was fighting against all the hatred with, of course, Rajdeep chipping in with his usual blunt and fair comments!

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 13th, 2007 9:34 pm

Looks like Huricane Katerina came here ….while I was away….

Whatever you guys say koi pharak nai penda!

Apunko to bas masti karna hai!

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 13th, 2007 8:07 pm

Thanks Galactico, For your expert comments!
ROFL!!!

Reply to this comment
Galactico on October 13th, 2007 7:53 pm

Aneek will never be a success bollywood singer, coz he’s copying Sonu Nigam all the time.He may be the winner of srgm but who will stop Raja from being the king of the music industry.

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 13th, 2007 7:42 pm

Joel,
Those who are oldtimers in this website know that Amanat was my favourite from the very begining. I said it at least 30 times!
When all three reached the finals I voted for all three because each is unique in his own way. Aanshi did that too!

Two days back I wrote to Dhirani that given the choice of Devil and Deep Sea, whom will you chose?

Public voting is totally unpredictable and when the format states that one can vote unlimited to one contestants then someone has to suffer! Its not the question of Bengali or non bengali.

Please understand that this is not the end but the begining of all these finalists!
Some people are behaving as if the world has come to an end!

Anyway, no hard feelings I hope?
Be happy my friend!

Reply to this comment
aminali on October 13th, 2007 7:37 pm

Rajdeep!
I did not say that Indians are racist. Between India and Pakistan I can sincerely say that Pakistanis are more racist than Indians! What I am saying is that Amanat is a much better singer than Aneek or Raja and that has been seconded by many epople who are guests of SRGMP! I am just pointing out that Aneek wins does not mean that the best person won but instead it shows that the janta decision is leasning towards biaseness for India and thats it.
If Amanat had won how can you say that the show is rigged when the majority of voters are Indians and the management of the show is Indian! You can argue as to who said what about the contestants but be true to yourself and say what you feel after peformances by Amanat and after what the guests said with feelings that you can see in their faces and voices.You can say that Jagjit or Pt. Jasraj only meant for that particular episodes but you must be deceiving yourself if that is so.
Let us not prolong this anymore lets see the success rate of Amanat, Aneek and Raja in the future.
This is of course due to the generousity of the Indian film /music industry and not the Indian janta!

Reply to this comment
musicfan on October 13th, 2007 7:16 pm

And sheetal dear a special thanks to you and your love for aneek.

Reply to this comment
musicfan on October 13th, 2007 7:14 pm

All aneek fans, we cannot convince some of the unreasonable people in this forum. so just calm down guys and enjoy the victory.

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 7:09 pm

ANd many more i can’t remember for now.

Take care guys.

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 7:05 pm

Sandipb,

I did not reacted to hurt anyone my friend.

If Amanat is your favorite why can’t you say on forum it was wrong. AND why vote for all 3.

What Iam trying say all the time:

Aneek is very young for that. Offcourse, he is good singer. He can be a Bengal champ or little champ. (bengle also made error. there are thousands of singer in bengal could sing better than Aneek).

But why can’t u acccept the fact that everyone played a game starting from Zee TV, HR and all campaigne starting from movie stars, tv channels etc.

Why can’t all bengal / indians accept this error. Aneek is begali means do we have to defend him or be fair to everyone.

Indian music for entire world now, spread its wing saloche to everywhere.

How about all indian can’t say a little sentence

We made a wrong decisions.

Think about that this is not indian IDOL or star voice. This is for entire world.

Putting 3 on final its a set up to have aneek winner.

A stupid can understand.

We all cannot ever say a single word to Zee TV and mentors this is wrong.

Thx and I quit.

TC guys

Note: I like few guys here including you, Being fair, Sheetal, Aanshi, Jenny, Siddarth, Rajdeep, Jaihind, shaz, Aajantha, hafeez, aminali, sharibahi, Sameera

Note: Sandipb keep it up man

Reply to this comment
rajdeep on October 13th, 2007 6:55 pm

Aminali,
Kunal Ganjawala is SRGMP product but I talked only about winners! And I said those who didn’t win are successful. You totally missed my point! Is it intentional?
And I also said Indians voted for all pakistani singers more than Pakistani people! Does it prove indians are biased?
What actually you want to hear from us?
Indians are racist? That will quench your anger?

BTW Only Jagjit singh told Amanat that he is the winner of “THAT EPISODE ONLY!!!”
Jasraj ji said “Raja is Raja!”
V-S said” Aneek is a kickass singer”, “We want to see Aneek as number 1″
ID said” I pray to Allah that Aneek wins”

If you want to argue then let us discuss every single detail and just not pick and chose what we like! OK?
Tell me frankly what is your problem?
If Amanat had won, could you justified to Raja’s fans that the show was not rigged?

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 13th, 2007 6:45 pm

Hey Galactico and Shaz,
SHUT UP. I have had enough!
I was trying to be very reasonable, but hate this mentality of yours!
What do you mean that we indians look at a singers background and religion?
Do you know how many singers and musicians of various backgrounds and religions and even from neighbouring countries are highly respected by us?
Do you know?
First preach those big things at your home and then blame us!

And Shaz, I have personally spent over $300 voting for Amanat from the begining. Can you tell me how much you have spent voting for an Indian contestant?
If you can’t then please shut your crap!
You have been successful to make me angry!

Reply to this comment
aminali on October 13th, 2007 6:43 pm

Rajdeep - IO am not going to prolong this argument as you seem not to understand what I said.You do not answer my arguments point by point but instead portray that I am anti Indian and pro Amanat. If I am wrong that it is fair to conclude that India is a country just like Pakistan with biased people and screwed up thinking process.( As for me I said earlier that
“in democracy and level headedness, I thought Indis is far ahead of Pakistan!!” But you seem to me as equating the 2 standards)
And if I am pro Amanat than I am just like all the mentors of SRGMP including HR, Pandit Jasraj, Jagjit Singh, Dia Mirza, Sanjay Gupta etc. etc. who thinks that Amanat is the real winner of SRGMP.Period!!
By the way I thought Kunal Ganjawala is also a product of SRGMP.

Reply to this comment
shaz on October 13th, 2007 6:37 pm

we amanat fans dnt want to blame indians but wat else can be the reason 4 why qamanat didn’t win? amanat was the best and is the best

Reply to this comment
Galactico on October 13th, 2007 6:35 pm

Look if you want to choose a singer, you mus’t look at his backround,where he comes from,from which religuous he is,whether he is a moslim or a non-muslim.You must choose a singer on his voice basic,on his capbility,on his knowledge.Music is for one and for all.Nowadays people have started listening music with their eyes and not with their ears.Remember one thing that music was created by the world and not just indians.

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 13th, 2007 6:30 pm

Aanshi,
I have given up all hope!
They don’t even believe that Amanat was my favourite too and I used to send 10 SMS to all three contestants every week!

But I am shocked to see Joel’s reaction! I thought he was very reasonable!
For others, they simply don’t want to listen.
They just want to blame anybody Indian!

Reply to this comment
Aanshi on October 13th, 2007 6:23 pm

Shanai.. and Sharibhai..

What are you congratulating me for? Because Aneek won..

I am happy for Aneek.. BUT PLEASE UNDERSTAND THIS HE IS NOT MY FAVORITE.. I have said this repeatedly.. when you guys dont doubt anyone else here.. why you always doubt me.. Am I so difficult to understand.. If you read my previous posts you will always see I HAVE ALWAYS SAID AMANAT IS MY FAVORITE..

It was just last week when I saw all 3’s performances.. I started voting for all three.. till then I was just voting for Amanat..

Sandip, Jenny.. please guys.. say something to these people.. please support me..

And please dont bash me.. As it is I am not happy with results today..

Reply to this comment
sharibhai on October 13th, 2007 5:40 pm

i jus wana say something b4 i go to aanshi i tink that uv dun a great job2get wat u wanted in the first place2mak aneek win and do admit it as every1 wont hate u if u jus blody honest.to the voting public now that we r goin to little champs plz giv these internatonal kids sum recognition wen they if they r gud of course and suport them as u wud to india giv them respect.the competition will be like how aneek jus won so dont mak it predictab we need sum1 diff provide the person is great.cherio

Reply to this comment
sharibhai on October 13th, 2007 5:33 pm

to every1 in this forum plz dont compare india and pakistand cos u cant compare the 2.remember wen india cricket team toured ther they got magnificient hospitality and all that.wen paki cricket team tour ther nun of that.so luk at the saregamapa challenge 2007 its a disgrace amanat shudv won.

Reply to this comment
rajdeep on October 13th, 2007 5:18 pm

Aminali,
To answer your questionsâ€¦
So tell me has the Indian janta been fair with the Pakistani singers?
Yes. First they didnâ€™t want anybody to be eliminated. Second, Indian people only voted for them in majority compared to Pakistani people (it is a proven fact) and third Indians gave them a break in different music albums?

Now my questions.

1.Who in the world knew about Amanat, Mussarat and Junaid if it not for the Indians?
2. Can you name any single winner of SRGMP show other than Shreya Ghoshal since 1997 who has made big in Bollywood? So why pick on Debojit alone?
In fact, those who didnâ€™t win made it big. So you should be happy!

Please do not argue just for arguments sake!

Reply to this comment
shaz on October 13th, 2007 5:14 pm

And the reason why no singers from india go to pakistan is because you only make it big in india. You can say india is where a singers dream will come true. Good singers from pakistan have gone to india for that reason..like adnan sami, atif aslam….and from the movie awarapan roxen(toh phir ao)…nusrat fateh ali khan…and all this india is making the profit,,So please dnt think pakistani’s dnt respect indian music or cinema coz they do. But 2day amanat should of won or if not him then raja..
I have said this before as well raja sounds like sukwinder sing and kalash kher but he is not better then them so no need for him in film industry… ANEEK sounds like sonu nigam but not better then sonu sono need in film industry and trust me he has won but he wil fade..and last but not least amanat he does not sound like sonu, udit, shaan,sukwinder,kalash…no one

Reply to this comment
aminali on October 13th, 2007 5:09 pm

Rajdeep - do not equate Pakistani singers and public with those of India. That country is screwed up busy with religious biaseness and killing each other. But I thought India is different!! When you invite people from other country to sing in your contest, you must be fair and even with them and not comparing their country with yours!! In democracy and level headedness, I thought Indis is far ahead of Pakistan!!
So tell me has the Indian janta been fair with the Pakistani singers? I ask this question from the viewpoint of a person who is neither Indian nor Pakistani!

Reply to this comment
shaz on October 13th, 2007 5:06 pm

OH MY GOD!!! INDIA MAKES A LOT OF MONEY FROM PAKISTANIS THEY BUY CD’S..WATCH MOVIES ETC.
WHEN THERE IS CONCERT IN UK WHEN BOLLYWOOD STARS COME 70% OF THE PEOPLE COME ARE PAKI’S.

Reply to this comment
UKguru on October 13th, 2007 5:03 pm

Hi ,
I have mentioned it earlier in the forum that , I I have very specifically noticed that south guys fight with north and visa versa but when it comes to a Bengali then jointly all attacks bengalis.
What’s wrong with you guys? Have you guys seen Chak De? First we are indian. Please accept the reality, culturally bengalis are the best and being an Indian we should feel proud for them. Yes I have seen Bengalis are mostly goes in service rather than going into business , after talking with them what I realised is they know how to remain satisfied with minimum and through their cultural activities they find their satisfaction which other business communities finds in earning more money. So you can’t blame Bongs for that. It’s reality Debu , Ujjaini , Sanchita , Aneek all are bengali and before public voting judges only brought them forward in the respective competition.
Today in everyones house we have songs of SD, RD , Hemant kumar, Salil …so and so forth it’s never ending , so stop crying you can’t prove anything beside proving yourself fool.

Reply to this comment
sharibhai on October 13th, 2007 5:02 pm

gud to see u back again shaz but so disapnted amanat lost i jus want2cry i know i shudnt as im a guy but im teribly hurt.if this is how the public is going to vote then therz nope use wathcing and supportin any1 internationally cos india has the majorit vote

Reply to this comment
rajdeep on October 13th, 2007 5:01 pm

Shaz,
I know majority of the Amanat fans are on the web poll.
We Aneek fans are rejoicing!
And you are axing your own head! We Indians know how to respect good singers!
Ask your country’s singers about us and also ask them why you don’t show the same respect to our singers and rarely invite them to your country

Reply to this comment
shaz on October 13th, 2007 4:58 pm

PAKISTAN KE MAHABALI AMANAT ALI IS THE BEST!!!

Reply to this comment
sharibhai on October 13th, 2007 4:57 pm

to all the raja and aneek fans jus shuddup ur da reason why india is going to have problems wid their musical talent by voting ota politics and regions and nope musical sense at all.

Reply to this comment
shaz on October 13th, 2007 4:57 pm

aminali you are 100% correct. RAJDEEP on the web pole majority are with amanat.

the ruth hurts you know your bias and fact is amanat is pakistani and under no condition u should let a pakistani win especially in india..huh that a not can do situation

Reply to this comment
rajdeep on October 13th, 2007 4:52 pm

You said it correctly for the first time!
You Amanat and Raja fans were busy bashing Aneek while we Aneek fans were busy voting for him!
If you had stopped the bashing and used your active support towards your favourites, perhaps the result would have been different!
You expected us to vote for your favourites while you sit quitely and when it didn’t happen you started the “blame Indian” game!

Reply to this comment
aminali on October 13th, 2007 4:42 pm

Rajdeep - your one line comments is not going to stamp out the truth!! Answer what I said item by item and see where you stand.I am not a Pakistani not Indian and I speak with no sentiments attached, like you! The truth has to be spoken and even stars that matter, like you know who!! have said before the contest that Amanat is already the winner because of his voice quality and versatility.So you go and tell the marines,with your one line answers, that I am talking crap!!
Also look at the online poll that is going on now, 3000+ people have already said that Aneek does not deserve to win and Amanat should!

Reply to this comment
BollyWoodFunda on October 13th, 2007 4:40 pm

AMANAT ALI WAS (HE IS STILL BEST) BEST

Reply to this comment
dshah on October 13th, 2007 4:35 pm

Dear Rajdeep and Siddharth - I am Marathi too
Jay Maharashtra!

Reply to this comment
rajdeep on October 13th, 2007 4:28 pm

aminali ,
Grapes are sour?

Stop whinning about India and Pakistan!
Your favourite cannot win by playing that crap card!

Reply to this comment
rajdeep on October 13th, 2007 4:26 pm

Dear Siddharth,
I am a proud Marathi too!
My name is Rajdeep Godbole and I am from Pune originally!

Reply to this comment
Siddharth on October 13th, 2007 4:11 pm

Dear mhharsha, Bengalis are very bad.
Dear Rajdeep, Bengalis are the best.

I am proud to be a marathi but still I respect the Bengalis. Because Bengalis are Indians and I am an Indian.

Both of you guys, please stop the crap.

Hi Moderator - please delete all these abusive comments. This is making the environment bad. Please!!!

Reply to this comment
sharibhai on October 13th, 2007 4:07 pm

i wud jsu like to say that im ashamed and disgraced tht india who could host an internationl show wid them can be so rotten to pakistan.if they didn want any2participat then they shud ve dun so tink abt it y bring them2humuliate them.this aint u music show but a sho of politics.

Reply to this comment
aminali on October 13th, 2007 4:01 pm

The results shows that the Indiasn janta sucks!! Just like the result last year where Debojit won and this year Indian Idol where Prashant Tamang won, the results show it is always the mediocre contestant who wins!!The most versatile, consistant and fantastic singer is Amanat and ,being a Pakistani,it is a forgone conclusion that he will never win because of the biaseness of the Indian janta.
Anyway is is good for you, Amanat that you did not come out on tops! Being No. 1 does not mean that your future is assured. Look at Debojit - what happened to him, nothing is heard of him anymore. Looking at the recording industry as the medium, Amanat has got it made and he is already on his way to be a “rocking” playback singer. The recording he has already done and the ones lines up for him shows that , in the eyes of the music/film industry ( the one that matters). Amanat is already the winner (as said by many including Pandit Jasraj,Jagjit Singh and even the opponents mentors many a times.
The one thing that I hate a lot is that the the infamous Himesh Besharamiyya is smiling a lot and living in a fool’s paradise. I was hoping that the results will wipe out the stupid smile he puts up for Aneek everytime Aneek appears on stage and this is not to be. Anyway if this besharam guy is going to appear in future reality episodes of ZeeTV then as far as I am concerned sit will be goodbye to Zee as I do not have the patience to watch his antics on TV as I fear I will land up having the most zaniest and irritating behaviour as this mad guy!My family and I have decided to avoid this character as far as we can.

Good luck to Zee and my only wish is that they see the writing on the wall and live up to what is expected of them.

Reply to this comment
shaz on October 13th, 2007 3:51 pm

I WAS JUST WATCHING STAR NEWS AND AMANAT DID NOT WIN BECAUSE PAKISTAN COULD NOT VOTE…I THINK THAT IS UNFAIR!!!!

WHAT DO U THINK GUYS..THAT UNFAIR ISN’T IT?

Reply to this comment
mhharsha on October 13th, 2007 3:50 pm

To Rajdeep…..
U r talking about four nobel prize to bengalis….though only 2 went to bengalis….
u guys considered urself as the most intelligent that why u r one of the poorest community in india….U alway make it issue of ur identity..bcs u guys are so afraid that u got united on these kind of stupid things….u do strike…u guys bring india to halt….u always look for govt jobs…always lives in group bcs not brave enough to chart out ur independent course….have u seen any bengali in business as compared to punjabi or gujrati…..Just bcs of u people british were able to rule india for such a long time….remebere east india company…..
u cheer when indian cricket team loose….
anyway its just waste of time beating head agaisnt wall…..I do not understand why u people dont start any movement to get separation from india…when u think whole india is against u guys

Reply to this comment
shaz on October 13th, 2007 3:48 pm

BELOW IS SANDEEPS VERSION OF WHAT SHOULD HAPPEN
BUT SECOND SHOULD BE AMANAT THIRD SHOULD BE RAJA AND FOURTH ANEEK
Champion: Musarrat
2. Aneek
3. Amanat
4. Poonam
5. Raja
6. Junaid
7. Harpreet
8. Sumedha

Reply to this comment
Cool_hunk on October 13th, 2007 3:45 pm

I think Aneek’s win is the defaet of good singing beacuse if singers like thease who try to mimic the orignal singers are declared winners by the and good singers who sing in their own voice are losers then it is a shame for all music lovers
it was pre planed long before the top three started and Himesh must had told the producer of the show to make his contestent the winner
from the begining he promoted Aneek because of his bullshit love story
it is a big big disaster for the music if singers like Aneek started winning just because of copying the orignal and try to gain publicity by doing all kinds of rubish things then any good singer will not come on this show
just thinking that if he is not a favourite of any guru of the show then he/she will not win the show despite of a good singing
If you would have seen the winning of Debojit then you have noticed that the whole crowed was cheering in the full voice and spirit but today after the announcement of the result the crowed was not cheering in the full voice and spirit even i heared on star news that people in the whole venue were expecting Raja to be the winner even when Raja was leaving the venue people outside were holding Raja’s posters even public was not happy by this decission
Ismail Darbar reacted by saying that if next season if something happens like this that in a wild card entry somone who is already a winner is brought in the middle of the show then he will not be in this show next year i think he was right because Amanat was also a winner of Saregamapa Middle East Challenge then he should also had came along with Aneek & Abhijeet
I think Aneek has cheated to become a winner Ismail Darbar tonted him repeatedly that “TU CHALTI GADI MEIN BAITHA HAI” and Manoj Bajpayee also said repeatedly about Amanat & Raja that “DEKH HIMESH YE KISI KI COPY NAHI KARTA APNI ORIGNAL AWAAZ MEIN GATA HAI”i think indirectly he was pointing towards Aneek that he mimics
If gurus like Himesh are in the show that show will not be sucessfull any more once more favouritism has won against a good and fair competion a disaster for good music

Reply to this comment
Siddharth on October 13th, 2007 3:30 pm

Hey Navi_Amanat, you sound very mad at Aneek and Aneek’s fans. Cool down. It is true that he was in third place, so he should have been eliminated. Same way, Raja was out of the competition. Zee TV brought him back, do you remember that. And, I liked that. He should have been. I felt that the Mahaguru’s decision was wrong to get Raja out of the show. But, Zee TV, did the right thing and brought him back. Same way, Amanat/Junaid/Musarrat were in bottom three and who knows who were at the bottom (hopefully not Amanat). So, all these things are immaterial. You are just trying to console yourself by telling this.

Don’t worry Navi_Amanat, Raja will get “roti”, “biriyani”, “chapati”…everything. He will not have to struggle if he is a genuine singer.

One thing is for sure, Musarrat and Amanat is going to rock Bollywood industry for sure very soon. And, I hope Aneek also will also have a very busy schedule for next coming years. I heard that he already started doing some playback in W Bengal. Definitely he will start doing it in Bollywood.

BTW, please stop this bengali/anti-bengali drama. you guys have started a cheap drama like Himesh again. After all, Aneek and Raja both are Indian. That is the first and last thing.

To me, again, Musarrat is the champion. Aneek and Amanat are the runners up.

Cheers!!!

Reply to this comment
raza on October 13th, 2007 3:25 pm

It was an overall good performances by all 3. So, congratulations to all 3. Now, on competition. Guysâ€¦this happens in any competition that someone has to win. Aneek has won this time around. So, congratulations to him. I wish all of them, and my very favorite Mussarat, Poonum, and Amanat to have sucess in everything they do, and in their lives. Thanks also, to the management of this website, to keep this event alive Thanks, Kind Regardsâ€¦Raza

Reply to this comment
Mubeen on October 13th, 2007 3:15 pm

wot eva haters aneeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeek won an none of u can do anyting bout it hahahahahahahahahahhahahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha u lot can cry if u wnt hahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahah aneeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeek iz the bst hahahahahahahahahahahahhahahaha amanat floped he was sad he fort he was gna win buh nooooooooooooooooooooo lol an himmesh rockkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkz allllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll the wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

Reply to this comment
rajdeep on October 13th, 2007 3:15 pm

eMmJaY ,
Do you think only international voters brought Amanat to top 3?

You are right. People like you should stop watching this program, so that we can have a healthy discussion in the forums and not face such trash!

Hope never to hear from your kind of people in future!

Reply to this comment
voiceofindia on October 13th, 2007 2:20 pm

@All Raja & Amanat’s fan

send email to your friends & everybody(as much as possible) STOP WATCHING ZEE AS UNFAIR SYSTEM.

Reply to this comment
eMmJaY on October 13th, 2007 2:06 pm

F—-g results, s—t voting, we should consider international voting as the results. Aneek should have been out of the contest long before. There is only one winner of Saregamapa 2007 and that is AMANAT ALI. International voting shows what I am saying. Stop watching such baised programs

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 2:03 pm

What ever happened guys. Being fair is really fair now.

We should not run after any state and its great people.

God bless all.

TC

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 13th, 2007 1:56 pm

I AM SO PROUD OF BENGAL!!

One of the most advanced communities in India.

So please don’t keep laughing at Bongs. Many people did it in this forum before.
Try accept the facts.

No offense please!

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 1:49 pm

kaya sandeep or sandipb; WHAT !!!!!!!!!!!!!

Who is Sandeep. I thought it was you

Oops man. That is why i got little upset how about our sandipb talk like.

You are my man. TC

LOL

Reply to this comment
rajdeep on October 13th, 2007 1:47 pm

To mhharsha,
You are absolutely right yaar!
Aeek Dhar sA RE GA ma pa Jeeta bahut na insaafi hua.

India mein eisa na insaafi kafi din se chal raha hai..

Jisko dekho usi ne benagli ke sath partiality karta hai..

Nobel prize dekho to 4 nobel prize kolkata main gaya (Rabindra nath, Mother Teresa, CV Raman [yes sir he was a professor in Calcutta] and haal hi mein Amartya Sen.

OSCAR walo ka bhi dimag thick nehi hai, pura bollywwod chod ke OSCAR dia Satyajit Ray ko..

AAB bolie keye karna chahie?

Dunia itna na insaaf i kiu karta hai bhai..koi to jowab do..

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 13th, 2007 1:42 pm

All three have really honed their performing skills in last few months. Look at their energy!

Jumping all over the stage still the voice is intact…!

Hats off to all 3 of you.

Amanat you made a difference inspite of being a foreigner!

especially for you!!!

You are simply AWESOME!!!

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 13th, 2007 1:42 pm

Hey its Sandip!
Sandeep is another gentleman!
You are so confusing! Get a cool beer buddy!

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 1:39 pm

Sandeep. thats a fair answer. goodman

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 13th, 2007 1:35 pm

Hi Joel!
Cool down. Why are you arguing?
I thought you to be a rational person!
Aneek has won, but that does not mean Amanat and Raja are losers!
All three alongwith Mussarat, Sumedha, Poonam will make their mark in future!
Who knows, maybe we will be watching their shows sitting side by side!

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 1:33 pm

being fair that was for you

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 1:33 pm

i did always love you man. you know it

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 1:32 pm

Rajdeep,

frustration for what my man.

We know that its gonna happen.

We are trying to open your eyes.

Do you remember HR and Ashaji battle on Mussarat.

That proves HR, Zee TV, and Power of abuse the system.

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 13th, 2007 1:30 pm

Chalo Shaney ne ekbar to bieng fair kaha!

Reply to this comment
rajdeep on October 13th, 2007 1:30 pm

Yes Navi_Amanat,
Amanat would also have been eliminated after the independence episode if the big hearted indians haven’t stood up for him!

And if Raja is so good why didn’t any of the mentors took him under his gharanain the first place?
Why was he put as a stand-by (Eklavya gharana)?
Have you ever thought of that?
It means the mentors knew that he has limited singing capacity!
He would have been voted out long ago if it isn’t for Bikaneer!
He was eliminated, remember? But then Bikaneer vote brought him back!

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 1:28 pm

ujjalcal

Your aneek alredy Won, why pointing and defending yourself now

What make you fear off. You did worng Decision!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! right

Great man. Its your day.

Being fair yes it was abhijeet. TKS

Reply to this comment
Navi_Amanat on October 13th, 2007 1:27 pm

Everybody knows that Aneek didnt deserve to be the winner.

ItS aLl AbOuT AmAnAt and RaJa!!!

Reply to this comment
rajdeep on October 13th, 2007 1:20 pm

Amanat’s fan and Raja’s fan will come out with sarcastic comments…which will be fun to read….frustration to nikalna hi pedega na!! are yaar hum bhi samjhte hain …apna favourite jab haar jati hain to yesa hi hata hain.

So Aneek’s fan sirf beyth ke tamasha dekho

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 13th, 2007 1:09 pm

Btw Shaney

Joy was not the state winner. Abhijit Kosambi was (along with Aneek).

Reply to this comment
Navi_Amanat on October 13th, 2007 1:09 pm

First of all Raja should’ve been first place. then it should have been Amanat as 1st runner up. then aneek was supposed to be 2nd runner up.

aneek would have lost if there was a elimination last week.

every year they pick a wrong person to be the winner. ex. debojeet shouldnt have been the winner. imean every year they mess up wats rong with u guys.

Reply to this comment
rospos on October 13th, 2007 1:07 pm

ujjalcal,
superb going, yaar. keep it up. well said dat de result speaks 4 itself. CHEERS YAAR.

Reply to this comment
ujjalcal on October 13th, 2007 1:02 pm

Thanks a lot there was no Bengali in your list of comments……..atleast you were that correct minded not include that in your list.

Shanai wrote –[[First three finalist choosen to have Annek in the contest (He would have gone if last elimination was there).]]
–>>no comments…..ANEEK is the winner, we all know that.

Shanai wrote –[[Second Amanat and Raja minority so they will battle within themselves.]]
–>> this prog is watched by international audiences, and the people whom you are calling minority is not minority in the whole world.

Shanai wrote –[[Third Aneek and joy is state winner and in the middle of the shaw choosed them to have fight with mussarat, poonam, raja and amanat]]
–>> no comments–ANEEK is the winner we all know that.

Shanai wrote –[[fourth all movie stars and HR comments direclty choosing him as favorite is totaly wrong. Like I said when judges there and guests judges too they should allow to comment on singing BUT NOT TALKING SIDES.]]
–>> HR supported his candidate, I think people have got ears to decide you is the best, and they have done that.

Shanai wrote –[[Fifth All publicity for Aneek around india including Zee TV hangma favor to Aneek.]]
–>>that was done for RAJA too….

Shanai wrote –[[Its a great campaign for AnEEK by HR and Zee tv to have a growing star is the sudden death sit.]]
–>> total out of the track comments by you….

–>> I thought you were going to give some facts about racism and how it helped ANEEK to win. Please take some rest, think and come back with some strong points..

Reply to this comment
rospos on October 13th, 2007 12:59 pm

ooooooooh sum1 sounds angry, eh nimal? is it dat bad, dude? yeh future shuture ki baatein apne paas hi rakh na, yaar. chal aneek ko energy drink bhi pila denge. philhal tu thand rakh, boss. gussa mat ho LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSER
(UH- OH! 4GOT U DON’T LIKE EMOTICONS,eh?)
bye nimal urf crybaby !!

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 12:53 pm

Hey all Raja, amanat, poonam, mauli, shumeda, mussarat, joy, abhijit(i liked him), juned and sumana fan

Lets go and maste banate for ANEEK.

LOL

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 12:49 pm

Ujjalcal,

First three finalist choosen to have Annek in the contest (He would have gone if last elimination was there).

Second Amanat and Raja minority so they will battle within themselves.

Third Aneek and joy is state winner and in the middle of the shaw choosed them to have fight with mussarat, poonam, raja and amanat

fourth all movie stars and HR comments direclty choosing him as favorite is totaly wrong. Like I said when judges there and guests judges too they should allow to comment on singing BUT NOT TALKING SIDES.

Fifth All publicity for Aneek around india including Zee TV hangma favor to Aneek.

Its a great campaign for AnEEK by HR and Zee tv to have a growing star is the sudden death sit.

Anyways, I guess this is pointless talking.

You can define all these if think closely.

Raja and amanat was not a HR promotion. They fought for their place and this is truth.

I hope you will understand one-day.

TC

Reply to this comment
abhat on October 13th, 2007 12:40 pm

Letâ€™s celebrate, letâ€™s rock !!! I am logging out too, had enough of these losers.

Reply to this comment
ujjalcal on October 13th, 2007 12:37 pm

Shanai,

Briefly can you describe how racism is involved?

Reply to this comment
paki44 on October 13th, 2007 12:34 pm

did u guyzz realiza Ismail Darbar was mad when they announces AMANAT 2nd RUNNER Up….he said AMANAT U WILL ALWAYZZ BE #1!!!!INSHALLAH AMANAT WILL GO VERY FAR IN LIFE….BEST WISHES…but then out of raja and aneek….RAJA shud’ve won!

Reply to this comment
rospos on October 13th, 2007 12:33 pm

well said siddharth.
n y de hell r we discussing hr? its aneek’s win we should b applauding. nywaz i’m logging out. and all aneek fans do de same n celebrate rather dan arguing with de stupid losers.
hip hip hurray

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 12:32 pm

Ujjalcal, What you are excited for. for Aneek. Ok man congrats

I am not that excited since its started because of HR.

This shaw is fully HR dominated, partial, don’t take it otherwise but racism too.

But when media/music/movie industry went to rule the world we have to be fair.

This is what i am talking about

and that could only prove you are true Indian when you judge right.

Aneek is 18 yr old and definitely great singer but he is in not that great or ready to win this.

Reply to this comment
Siddharth on October 13th, 2007 12:31 pm

Hi Moderator, could you please remove invinciblez’s awful comment?

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 13th, 2007 12:30 pm

I agree Siddharth ,
But instead of Harpreet my choice would be Sikander!
I don’t know if you remember him. He has a golden voice!

Reply to this comment
ujjalcal on October 13th, 2007 12:26 pm

I also didnt like the HR comments………that was bad.

Reply to this comment
Siddharth on October 13th, 2007 12:26 pm

Guys…Aneek won the crown as I expected and I am very happy for him. But at the same time I feel very sad for Amanat Ali. He has awesome voice. Anyway, he will surely shine in few days…you guys will see that. Hope Aneek does more hard work and becomes successful like Sonu, KK or Shaan. He should not be like Debojit or Vineet. People forgets very fast. Aneek and Amanat needs to continue their rewaz and be the true champion. My wishes to Raja too who came to this stage of the competition. I wish him all success.

Guys, one more request, please don’t bing here any bengali/rajasthani/Amanat fight. I am from Mumbai and I liked Aneek and Amanat both and it does not mean that only Pakistanis voted for Amanat or only bengalis voted for Aneek.

I know that the argument will keep going between Amanat/Aneek and Raja fans. Personally this is my choice:

Champion: Musarrat
2. Aneek
3. Amanat
4. Poonam
5. Raja
6. Junaid
7. Harpreet
8. Sumedha

Finally, a huge applause for the person who hosted this website and gifted the videos for us. Thanks a lot for you. Please keep doing the great job. Thank you again!!!

Reply to this comment
invinciblez on October 13th, 2007 12:23 pm

HR dint stop talkin till the end … he dint want raja to win, clearly shows from the comments he made when akshay was gonna annouce the winner… he shd b kicked out from saregama ….

COMMENT EDITED - DONT ABUSE ANYONE HERE..

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 13th, 2007 12:22 pm

Baki sab baju hato! Aneek fans ko enjoy karne do!

Aneek!!!I am enjoying your show to ultimate!

You deserve it no matter what.

You got the blessings from -Kishoreda,Bhupenda,Panchamda,….evryone…!
YOu rock! you r cool!

We are proud of you!

Reply to this comment
ujjalcal on October 13th, 2007 12:20 pm

Shanai,

you are making mistakes, you need rest…….you are calling Rajdeep as sandipb……
The biggest mistake you did was that you supoorted RAJA and hated ANEEK…….

take rest

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 12:19 pm

is shetall here!!

my libra baby congrats.

I am realy happy for you.

bithday wishes came true

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 12:17 pm

hey sandipb sorry year that was for rajdeep

Reply to this comment
rospos on October 13th, 2007 12:15 pm

CHEERS 2 ALL WHO SUPPORTED ANEEK
WE NEEDN’T SAY NYTHING MORE. THE VERDICT IS OUT. LET’S REJOICE N IGNORE THOSE SILLY CRYBABIES WHO WILL KEEP ON BABBLING BOUT RIGGED POLLS etc.
GROW UP MORONS, TAK DE RESULT SPORTINGLY. WE ALL KNOW ALL 3 R GR8. BEST OF LUCK 2 BOTH RAJA N AMANAT. AS 4 ANEEK U ROCK MAN. ALL FANS OF ANEEK PLZ IGNORE THOSE LOSERS N SAVOR DE MOMENT

Reply to this comment
Nimal on October 13th, 2007 12:12 pm

ujjalcal : clearly this is not aboyut music its about being bengali.
LOSER SUPPORTER OF LOSER ANEEK.
PEACE OUT!
THIS FORUM NO LONGER DESERVES MY COMMENTS AND TIME.
amanat and raja zindabad. Aneek FLOP-ABAD! LOL

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 13th, 2007 12:12 pm

Shanai,
What did I forecast!
Are you confusing me with Sandeep or Rajdeep?

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 12:11 pm

Sorry If I said something taht hurt you and aneek fan.

Ho do you think that binaner (its a small town) got 70% for him.

this what happen to American idol, Canadian IDOL.
All state support their own.

again / Still truth always comes-out in those countries saw.

At least they can make real gem winner.

Reply to this comment
ujjalcal on October 13th, 2007 12:11 pm

BENGALI Zindabad………

All Bengal Heros ZINDABAD.
KISHORE KUMAR Zindabad,
R D Burman Zindabad
S D Burman Zindabad

and the list continues…..

ANEEK HATERS….BENGALI HATERS……MURDABAD

Reply to this comment
Nimal on October 13th, 2007 12:10 pm

sandip yep that clearly makes you one.
aneek = loser

winner= amanat and raja

aneek can you start drinking some protein shakes? and finally grow up a bit? loser !

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 13th, 2007 12:09 pm

Shanai,
I am never afraid to call a spade a spade!
Look at the barrage of abuses and judge for yourself!

And incidently I congratulated all three unlike so many Aneek bashers!
So does that make me a “stupid Aneek fan?”

Reply to this comment
Nimal on October 13th, 2007 12:08 pm

vote4indian, rospos, and ujjalac you guys take it easy with the balloons and emoticons! keep the celebrations within the bengali community coz i dont think anyone is cheering for the retarded shorty aneek. Did you guys miss the audience reaction? No one hardly cheered for aneek, they were voting for raja! And while we were sharing oru thoughts on how Aneek doesnt deserve to win, we did continue to vote for ur favorites. But guess what, in a preplanned show cant do much can ya??? that works out for losers like aneek and his supporters? But for the rest of teh world who has enough sense, we all know better. Why else would people know 2-3 weeks in advance on who is going to win? About the pre-planned winnner? Got it? So, all i can say is wait and see how aneek flops in life and raja and amanat succeed. Then you can vote for aneek all you want to get him big in life! Physically and professionally! lol
Oh btw now that he is a winner, give him some protein shakes so the BOY can grow up to be a MAN!And hopefully sound like one too, looking like one will perhaps still be difficult! haha
Okay losers (those who support aneek) May God show you the truth in the near future!!!!!!!! Sa re ga ma pa sucks….. they could have never made amanat won from a different country, and raja well , i dont know why they picked aneek over him!

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 12:06 pm

Rajdeep and aneek few extreme lover.

You should feel shame what happend.

its not that i want amanat or Raja to win.

Its about people watching the saw around the world will think you guys are Hippocrates.

sorry to say that you all never brave enough to face the truth.

And religion fact came first and then Bengali.

You did kill the music industry make him winner

Sandeep you had forecast on earlier means you knew this gonna happen. So, what is the impact.

MEANS what

Then why bothering having this world telent shaw

We need to define word telent again for bangali

If Aneek was such singer I would have put myself on the line.

But I knew it too.

God bless Aneek amanat and Raja

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 13th, 2007 12:02 pm

Shanai,
Thanks for your congrats and I am truely sorry for you!

A sincere request for you please!
Before you make your comment against any race , please do your homework first.

Since the day public voting started Raja always got more than 70% votes only from Bikaneer!
And that is the reason why Poonam, Sumedha, Mussarat got eliminated!
Please do not bash us bengalis.
Bikaneer people thought that they can make another winnere; but this is not Indian Idol, this is SRGMP where adult people vote maximum (unlike teenagers in Indian idol).

If you can prove me wrong I will apologize to you but in the fianl voting round Raja got more than 70% votes from Bikaneer only!
Aneek and Amanat got the max. votes from rest of India. So if you ignore Bikaneer then Amanat would have been second!

Reply to this comment
ujjalcal on October 13th, 2007 12:01 pm

Shanai

you are confident Raja is going to be the best seller……fine done.

now please go to sleep….let us the Aneek fans enjoy the WIN…

ANEEK CONGRATS

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 13th, 2007 12:01 pm

Rajdeep,

Yeah! Yeah! I remeber!

Now that Aneek won: So the voting is rigged..

Bengalis already got the blow. Rest of India is yet to get a name in a minute or two.

By the way Mr Shane - I am not Bengali …I am an Assamese

sonali

Reply to this comment
vote4indian on October 13th, 2007 11:59 am

AS ujjalcal SAID,,,,,,,
JO JEETA WOHI SIKANDAR

ANEEK you were the best YOU ARE THE BEST AND YOU WILL B the best :ange:angel:l:

CONGRATS ANEEK N HIMESH

I KNW SOME PPL NEVER ACCEPT THE TRUTH ,,,N NEVER SEE ANYONE TO GET SUCCEED,,, ,,SO JUS CHIILLL OUT. ..COZ….ANEEK IS THE BEST SINGER….AS V ALL KNW….

Reply to this comment
abhat on October 13th, 2007 11:58 am

Hey folks, stop your conspiracy theory bs. Accept the winner, he is the best.

Reply to this comment
imranhashmi23 on October 13th, 2007 11:58 am

raja dost , don’t worry yaar u were the best and aneek stands no where in front of u .Aneek is very self centred person and after winning he not even once saw u ,that shows how selfish he is ,anyways don’t odnnt dost life don’t ends at this grand flop finaly of sa re ga ma . ,n life means changes so just take a chill and work again and prove this world tht how the results of this show was pre dicided other wise u r the winner …….. best of luck dost .

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 11:57 am

Sandeepb,

I am shocked when you said now people will so-many thing.

I had a feeling at least you are one person would the facts with truth.

But you are none other than stupid aneek fan,

Can’t u guys open your eyes and think winning a big singing contract for aneek is too early.

You know what did to him. Hi did spoiled him and he will another bappida.

Note my comment it will help you to realize how stupid india has made.

God bless u Raja

Reply to this comment
ujjalcal on October 13th, 2007 11:57 am

Hey you frustrated bunch of clowns, till now you have hated Aneek and you are abusing Bengali’s…..

Talking about British rule and other stuff, what funny cahracter……….

ANEEK CONGRATS once agin to you…….

BENGALI Zindabad, Kishore Kumar Zindabad, R D Burman zindabad, S D Burman Zindabad……All the great heros of BENGAL zindabad…….

Reply to this comment
piya on October 13th, 2007 11:56 am

FIRST OF ALL 3 CLAPS FOR DHIRANI
BECZ YESTERDAY ONLY HE ONLY DECLARED ANEEK TO BE THE WINNER AS HE GOT THE NEWS FROM SOMEWHERE.
EVERYTHING WAS “PREPLANNED”
BECZ CONSIDERING WHOLE AUDIENCE PRESENT OVER THERE AS OUR WHOLE BHARTIYA JANTA
IT’S 100% SURE THAT RAJA SHOULD BE THE WINNER
BECZ THEY ALL WERE SCREAMING FOR RAJA N NO EVEN ONE CAN DENY FROM THAT.

Reply to this comment
rospos on October 13th, 2007 11:54 am

to all u aneek haters,
the boy has proved himself. whoever said dis fight shouldn’t occur is very correct. and my man (whoever u r )who said de thing bout bogus votes,my heart felt sympathies 4 u
but wat 2 do, people lik u were so busy criticising aneek dat perhaps u 4got to vote 4 ur favourite.
got de point, suckers?????
still congrats raja n amanat- u both r damn good..
CHHEERS ANEEK

Reply to this comment
abhat on October 13th, 2007 11:54 am

Aneek, you did it ! You are the best !

Reply to this comment
rajdeep on October 13th, 2007 11:53 am

Sonali, Sheetal, voteforindian, musicfan. markwaugh,

What did I predict on my forum on Oct 6th?

See the comments from Aneek haters?
Didn’t I predict exactly the same words?
Ha! Ha! Ha!

Reply to this comment
imranhashmi23 on October 13th, 2007 11:53 am

sa re ga ma pa’s grand finaly is a big flop in the end and no one in the world will see now this show its a big flop in the end .

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 11:53 am

Jenny, guests, jai hind, Ajantha, all raja fan

Keep it cool. Raja will the best seller soon.

This is my all religion belief.

God bless Raja.

you are always number 1 no matter what hr or Saree Zee TV.

Reply to this comment
Nimal on October 13th, 2007 11:52 am

i feel like puking at aneek’s win! ujjalcal you really need to know what best is! u sure u can define the word? aneek is anything but the best. oh how he pisses me off including his cheapoo guru himesh. Even afer what dia mirza said in the last show,,,, hope that everyone in our country votes for amanat…guess the country didnt listen yet again! oh well… my last comment here. peace out everyone and the final was a pathetic show.
Raja and Amanat will go way ahead in their career than the average voice singer aneek the shorty!

Reply to this comment
vote4indian on October 13th, 2007 11:50 am

CONGRATZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ…. ……ANEEK..THE BEST SINGER. N WISH A GOODLUCK TO AMANAT N RAJA………

Reply to this comment
imranhashmi23 on October 13th, 2007 11:50 am

Hello nilam ,

We correct said nilam , u r right raja should have been the winner instead of this stupid aneek and future will tell results also ,anyways i will also leave watching sa re ga ma from now and similarly whole india will leave this watch now ,its a pre planned dicition and not on the public votes ……….

Reply to this comment
Shanai on October 13th, 2007 11:49 am

Sandeepb, never being fair, shetall and all includign aanshi !! I am happy for you guys.
No personal attack okay.

Congrats Aneek,

But Sorry I cannot say that I am happy for you.

Thank you MH harsha. You are 100% true.

Dhuk ki bath, we did not change ourselves since 3 hundred years when all british started coming. We love ghush, uthkuch, chamcagiri and cheating others. we love to do always flirt with the wrong trend.

I think none of bangali did think for other contestant.

This is so unfair.

Amanat could win but he is from less populated Pakistan

Raja should win. This is truth.

One day bangal will realize their mistake but it will be too late for people creating a great generation.

Truth ka saat dena all human duty. Faraj bantahe.

God bless u guys.

Reply to this comment
ujjalcal on October 13th, 2007 11:48 am

o Jeeta Wohi Sikandar,
ANEEK you were the best, are the best and will be th best……….

CONGRATS ANEEK

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 13th, 2007 11:47 am

Aneek, Amanat, Poonam, Mussarat, Raja, Sumedha, and Abhijit Kosambi (yap he too!) …..you all ROCK!!!

Reply to this comment
vote4indian on October 13th, 2007 11:47 am

ANEEK N HIMESH. …BOTH ROCKS….THE SAREGAMA SHOW…. ….I WISH THM ALL THE BEST

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 13th, 2007 11:47 am

Exactly paki44,
It was a closely fought contest and like you people should praise all three.
But see the trend! Already hatred started falling!
And they call themselves music lovers!
My favourite Amanat also lost.
If these are music lovers then a cockroach is also a bird!

Reply to this comment
Nimal on October 13th, 2007 11:45 am

sorry got the names mixed up in my earlier comments.. i meant to say ” Frankly speaking Aneek and HImesh both make me literally sick!”

Reply to this comment
vote4indian on October 13th, 2007 11:45 am

hey ……….
i told you ….ANEEK IS GOING TO WIN…..N TATZ IT…

ANEEK IS THE WINNER
:angel::party:

HEZ THE WINNER…….. FOR ALL ANEEK FANZ…. ITZ PARTY TIME…..

Reply to this comment
imranhashmi23 on October 13th, 2007 11:45 am

Hello All,

It seems the results have been menupulater as per the juides hold on the program and because of that only this stupid Aneek had won this show other wise he is suppost to be 3rd only not 1st and all had happend because of his guide himesha (biggest stupid of the world ) he had always supports him and demoreliced others i hate both these stupid hemish and his jodi go to well .

For all india now also raja is the winner of the show.

Reply to this comment
Nimal on October 13th, 2007 11:43 am

Total Bogus Votes!! This has to be pre-planned as someone said earlier in another forum. If there was anyone who deserved to win it was Amanat, but alas! Raja SHOULD have been the one, not Aneek.
Frankly speaking Raja and HImesh both make me literally sick! Aneek Mr. Shorty won the competition but hopefully will be put in his place in the future…time will tell who suceeds more! Raja and Amanat should have been the ones not the ordinary voice singer ANEEK… What a shame! I aint watching sa re ga ma pa ever again! That includes the little champs too! What a waste of my time and votes!!!!!!!!!!!

Reply to this comment
musicfan on October 13th, 2007 11:41 am

yipeeeeeeeeeeee congrats aneek.

Reply to this comment
guest on October 13th, 2007 11:40 am

The results are not fair,its clear becoz if he competetion is between Raja and Amanat , it would be Amanat I thought who would win, but between Raja and Aneek it should have been Raja…what nonsense HR was talking abt age as though someone just forced the youngest one into race,Raja is 25 and he says he is 27, hate HR for anything like this, very corrupted fellow.. SRGMP shd be careful enough not to pick younger ones into these shows otherwise all this crap happens .
Eventhough Aneek sings , it doesnt have such a feeling, its like having an elastic smile on face without a real heart in it..anyhow whatever happened , Raja is great..thats all

Reply to this comment
paki44 on October 13th, 2007 11:39 am

i wish all 3 the best for their future, but im also sad Amanat did not make it and the saddest part is that all 3 of them got 3 crores something votes….so the difference between 1st,2nd,3rd is only between a few thousand votes:(

Reply to this comment
sandipb on October 13th, 2007 11:37 am

Congratulations Aneek ! You deserve this for your versatility, your consistency and your technical perfectness!
Congratulations Amanat, again for your versatility and consistency!
Congratulationa Raja for your divine voice!

All three of you made us proud!

I know there will be people who will start throwing barrage of abuses to you because their favourite didn’t win, but the fact remains that all of you rock!

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 13th, 2007 11:36 am

Wow!! Look at the amount of oppulance in the final show!
Zee u made hell lot of money from our SMSs!

But Aneek you did it!!!

Reply to this comment
markwaugh15 on October 13th, 2007 11:35 am

all for you aneek and himesh
you both rock

Reply to this comment
sandeep on October 13th, 2007 11:31 am

Reply to this comment
markwaugh15 on October 13th, 2007 11:25 am

guys don’t think i’m calling raja and amanat bandars, i’m just calling those people who still fighting thinking they were better

Reply to this comment
markwaugh15 on October 13th, 2007 11:24 am

Mindblowing, outstanding, Fantastic
aneek and himesh are the best
Cheers mate
Jo jeeta woh sikandar jo haara woh bandarhehehehehehehehe

Reply to this comment
markwaugh15 on October 13th, 2007 11:23 am

Aneek well done dude you are the best

Reply to this comment
markwaugh15 on October 13th, 2007 11:22 am

i’m very happy that the most deserving candidate won,
aneek was the best of all the singers who took part
i would have been highly surprised if raja would have won, amanat being from pakistan lost out on many votes to be honest
raja is one dimensional singer

aneek you rock
himesh you rock as well

Reply to this comment
sheetal1210 on October 13th, 2007 11:19 am

hey Sonali i am so happy for him
andal the best to all three
I am spechless wil catch u later

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 13th, 2007 11:17 am

Come-on Sheetal,

it’s true! It’s true. TI’s very. No matter how much abuse or hatered he got!!

He made it.

also my best wishes to Amanat and Raja. They are no less anyway!!

-Sonali

Reply to this comment
sheetal1210 on October 13th, 2007 11:15 am

sandip tell me yaaar

Reply to this comment
sameera_a on October 13th, 2007 11:14 am

Aneek go to the hell.
raja zindabad Amant super star
Aneek murdabad

Reply to this comment
sheetal1210 on October 13th, 2007 11:14 am

And if it true I M SO HAPPY
Speechless
My little wonder made it
i m crying
me kamp rahi hu puri
hey bhagvan hop its true

Reply to this comment
sheetal1210 on October 13th, 2007 11:12 am

is this rigt? i m seeing online still yet nt decided who won??

Reply to this comment
beingfair on October 13th, 2007 11:11 am

Yeaaaaaaaaah!!!!!

Three cheers for Aneek Dhar!!!!!
You made my day!

Yeeeeaaaaaaaahhh!

Reply to this comment
mhharsha on October 13th, 2007 11:10 am

its the only Raja who deserved to win….the problem is all these bengalis is that they dont take it in a competition spirit…they always make it issue against bengali identity….and keep voting recklessley and keep defending their stupid heros, role models…thats why they are still one of poor community in india….and they will remain poor….bcs first communist are ruling them and second is bengalis becomes tottaly intellectually bankrupt…..they cheered if india lose in Eden Garden (bcs u removed ganguly)….actually they shld get merged with bangla desh….Jai Hind

Reply to this comment
kk_vissu on October 13th, 2007 11:03 am

Hi,

We all should be very happy for Aneek’s success.

So far This is the only one music contest which gave the correct result.I am really happy for this event.

Aneek Congratulations , you made it.

Reply to this comment
Chandra on October 13th, 2007 10:58 am

Who cares what you want, Jo jeeta wo Sikander,

after all he is Gem of all,so don’t get jealous and congratulate him,be honest and sporty.

Chandra Shah.

Reply to this comment
desipatel07 on October 13th, 2007 10:37 am

noooooooooooooooooooo

i dont want him to win

i dont like him
if he win then HR is goin to be so happy

Reply to this comment
sandeep on October 13th, 2007 10:32 am

Yo man! You rock! Tujhe salaam…

Reply to this comment