Faster access to SaReGaMaPa Challenge 2007
Get faster internet speeds by using


Spoiler - Whos Eliminated?


Spoiler for this week.. Whos Eliminated and Who has Topped the Chart..

Sumedha Karmahe of Bappi Lahiri’s Josh Gharana is the one Eliminated this week..

Good News for Raja Hasan fans - He has topped this week.. (I know how is going to be most happy in this forum…)

Toppers for the week -

  1. Raja Hasan
  2. Aneek Dhar
  3. Poonam Yadav
  4. Amanat Ali (In Bottom 2!!!…  :roll:)
  5. Sumedha Karmahe  (Eliminated…)

(This comes from a reliable source.. But bear with us if there are some changes… )

, , , , , , , , ,

Comments

87 Responses to “Spoiler - Whos Eliminated?”

  1. sonya on September 28th, 2007 5:08 am

    HR BEHAVE URSELF WHO DO U THINK U R FOR SHOVING ADITYA ASIDE ON THE KAREENA SHOW GET A LIFE. ANYWAY GOOD LUCK RAJA HOPE YOU WIN I LIKE pocket size`power house and a note to her hope u touh great heights i dint like the way hr mentioned u were getting sympathy votes nothing would better than watch him and his cheela get out of the show. aneek is desperate to get attention all these stories about his love affair dont amuse me suprisingly vineet of saregamapa 06 had a love story get a grip himesh running out of :idea: ssss i was happy to see harpreet back to perform on shows i was dissapointed when he left and it was the first time i cried on his elimination i think he deserved better

    Reply to this comment

  2. navneetthareja on September 25th, 2007 11:14 am

    I feel strongly that Poonam is the BEST. Yet the other 3 are no less. If all the Pakis went through a no elimination round because of ,whatever, even it is an established fact that, in this world of men … Women have to compete harder and have been deprived of opportunities for ages now. Happening yet again in this century. Why could SAREGAMAPA not think and hv FINALS in these four…. AND by the way the biased MCP gurus have to be thrown out for sure to respect the talent. A committee of Legends like Lata JI/Asha JI/Anand JI should be invited to choose the winner

    Reply to this comment

  3. brokeninside01 on September 22nd, 2007 11:35 am

    WHEN SUMEDHA WAS elminated what song did they play at the end of the show…it went something like this “betay lamhe jub he yaad ah tay hain” thats all I KNOW!…does anyone know who sang it & whats the name of the song? THANKS TO THOSE WHO CAN HELP =] :mrgreen:

    Reply to this comment

  4. Dhirani on September 21st, 2007 8:10 am

    Miss Khera,

    why are you so ecstatic and impatient and angry girl, lady, woman!!!!!!!!!!!! whatever

    take it easy or the brain surgeon will be at your back and rightly explaining you the pros and cons of your actions, heheheheheheh and another heart sergeon will crop up from somewhere too

    atleast agree to some of the things he says!!!

    Anyway as Amanat is out and Raja is to go next, things will calm down.

    Reply to this comment

  5. sandeep on September 21st, 2007 5:18 am

    Interesting comment in another forum - Raja has effeminate traits, specially sniffing into hankies. Now that I think about it…

    Reply to this comment

  6. MISS KHERA on September 21st, 2007 1:24 am

    Dear Sandip

    I did not say that you said aneek is better than anybody else, i said that even if you say it there is nothing wrong with it as it is your opinion…………don’t be afraid to put your opinion across!!!!!

    Why the hell do you always go on about education/inteligence/english…….what are you a brain surgeon???????

    No one ever questions you about education.

    Where are you from????? whats your profession????

    I love calling aneek a chipmunk as he reminds me of one……….for fun, i do not think that is abusive. Trust me there are alot worser words!!!! R u living in a bubble!!!!

    I agree with you that we shouldnt use abusive words, but here in the uk chipmunk is a cartoon character……………what is it in your country??? would be interested to know.

    Miss K

    Reply to this comment

  7. ArunSastry on September 21st, 2007 1:15 am

    I WOULD LOVE TO SEE THE FACE OF BAAAAPI DAAAAA AFTER SUMEDHA’S ELIMINATION. SORRY MOTU BETTER LUCK NEXT TIME. SHAKIRA & BRITNEY SPEARS BOTH ARE IN THEIR HOMES NOW. NOW U R JOBLESS ????????

    Reply to this comment

  8. ArunSastry on September 21st, 2007 1:11 am

    SANDIP I TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU THAT WHOEVER WINS THE CONTEST OF SAREGAMAPA WILL DESERVE IT.AT LEAST WE WILL NOT SEE SANDEEP ACHARYA OR PRASHANT TAMANG AS THE WINNER. NOW THE LAST FOUR ARE MUCH TALENTED, I HOPE THE DESERVING PERSON SHOULD WIN THE CONTEST. ALL THE GUYS ITS A REQUEST FROM ME THAT DON’T VOTE AS PER JUDGES COMMENTS, PLEASE DECIDE URSELF AND VOTE, STRAIGHT AWAY FROM HEART. :lol:

    Reply to this comment

  9. MISS KHERA on September 21st, 2007 12:51 am

    Sandip, go back and read commnets, read carefully!!!!!!!!!

    Reply to this comment

  10. Rocky on September 20th, 2007 11:30 pm

    Rajaa raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja HE IS THE BEST …….. HE SINGS SUPERB….. MAI YEK BAAT JAHENA CHAHTAHU KI JAB BI RAJA GATAHE TO USKI AAVAJ DIL SE AATHI HE AUR OH DIL KO CHUTIHE …..OH DIL DIL NAHI HOTE JISE RAJA KI AWAZ KO MAHASUS NA KARSAKE…..USKE AWAZ ME JAADU HE JO SUNNE WALEO KO INVOLVE KARDETA HAI SONG ME…..I FEEL AND BELEIVE SOOOOOOO……HE IS THE BEST …..ENJOYYYY ….FRIENDS….HAVE A NICE DAY :razz:

    Reply to this comment

  11. aps_athiyam on September 20th, 2007 2:58 pm

    I agree Raja really needs to improve his singing..I like him n don’t want him out but he really needs to be improve like his earlier songs. Hios last two songs were not so upto mark.

    Reply to this comment

  12. sandeep on September 20th, 2007 12:05 pm

    By the way, is Bappida joining Biggest Loser Jitega 2?

    Reply to this comment

  13. sandeep on September 20th, 2007 12:04 pm

    Its funny to read so much discussion about talent and that the best singer should win when the entire contest and the voters are geared up for multiple votes. I am not sure if multiple votes per person actually counts - but assuming it does, it is indeed a weird system. The show makes money out of the SMS and the contestant with the most “voting” clout wins. No wonder we get people like Sandeep Acharya and the Fame… singers. Atleast Saregamapa has a good bunch and whoever wins, no one will ever (ever??) be as ridiculous as Sandeep Acharya.

    Reply to this comment

  14. musicfan on September 20th, 2007 10:43 am

    @lady s
    i don’t agree with you. Raja is the weakest contestant in the show and should be voted out if he continues giving the bad peformances. His pardeshi and tenu leke were not upto the mark. However if he improves and come back with bang then i won’t have any problem. And your comment about aneek is very irrational.

    Reply to this comment

  15. aps_athiyam on September 20th, 2007 10:34 am

    well who told u Amanat is out..Sumedha is out…

    Reply to this comment

  16. Dhirani on September 20th, 2007 10:16 am

    Hey Guys,

    Unbelieable news. :oops:

    AMANAT has been voted out and not SUMEDHA as per today’s spoiler :twisted:

    This is really unbelievable :evil:

    However, from now on it will be 2 songs a piece, so the singers have to be more careful and so should the voters be.

    I am :sad: today

    Reply to this comment

  17. achar007 on September 20th, 2007 8:39 am

    Hi Guys,

    Let the deserving person win. Please, Please, Please. Please give it a thought before your vote. If you guys are also behaving like Himesh then how are you guys differnt from him. You then have no right to talk about his misdoings. Please judge people according to their merit and performance of the day. I personally feel Aneek has given a very consistent performance from the beginning and also tried songs of all generes. Poonam and Amanat stand next to him. Its a request to all of you, deserving candidates should not be eliminated because of any kind of bias.

    Good luck to all the contestants !!!

    007

    Reply to this comment

  18. lady s on September 20th, 2007 8:02 am

    :lol: Raja is no.1 & that’s where the Raja’s belong.I would love to watch Himass Besharammiya ’s face up close.next should be Oink Oink.I will double my voting for Raja from now on.

    Reply to this comment

  19. sandipb on September 20th, 2007 7:58 am

    Miss Khera,
    I have ALWAYS said that people have the right to vote for their favourite singers but should not abuse or make mockery of other singers!
    Can you please show me one example where I have said that!

    Unlike many others I love all the 12 finalists

    Reply to this comment

  20. Gopal Das on September 20th, 2007 5:57 am

    sumedha u can’t out from this stage bcause ur last performence is mindblowing and fantastic.>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> plese keep her until next episode

    Reply to this comment

  21. Jack123 on September 20th, 2007 5:13 am

    :smile: Very happy about Raja..

    Screw Himesh Resh..I was a big fan of him before I started watching Saregama..Now I know what kind of person he is..

    Reply to this comment

  22. simi on September 20th, 2007 4:37 am

    Love you SUMEDHA! If its true that ur eliminated…will miss u very much! :sad:

    Reply to this comment

  23. josh on September 20th, 2007 4:31 am

    guy’s don’t believe in rumors ,pls….keep sending your precious votes for raja hasan.

    Reply to this comment

  24. MISS KHERA on September 20th, 2007 4:25 am

    Hi all, so happy to hear that Raja has come through to the next round.

    Everyone should continue voting for their favourite singers, all the contestants in the competition at moment r good singers and that is why they have come so far.

    Sandip

    I can’t understand why you say that people should not vote for their favourite singers, of course people will vote for their favourite singers. They are not going to vote for someone they do not want to win.

    All the contestants have generally always sung well in the competition, so to stop voting for your favourite because they hadn’t sung well in one song, is silly. Everyone has a good and a bad day. When some one becomes your favourite singer, it is because they have sang extremely well and that is why they are close to the finals.

    Raja’s bad day was over-exaggerated by himass besharmya.

    I wouldnt vote for other singers as well……why waste your money!!!!! There is only going to be one champion in this competition.

    All the last 6 singers are winners, they have achieved alot and will continue to.

    I think the voting has been very sensible this week, with Raja on top!!!!!!!!!!!!. This will help with Raja’s confidence that was knocked down by HR. This is a good slap for HR!!!!!!! Can’t wait to see his face!!!!!!

    Reply to this comment

  25. imrohan on September 20th, 2007 1:52 am

    MISS U SUMEDHA, LOVE U SO MUUCH…….. :cry:

    Reply to this comment

  26. imrohan on September 20th, 2007 1:43 am

    hello everyone,i think sumedha was eliminated because she was said that ,she was basically from bihar ans she hurted people of chhattisgarh , people of chhattisgarh likes him very much, but for getting vote she said that and the result is here. raja is on top is good but he dosnt deserve on no #1# , because of HR annek will trouble , aneek be aware from HR, tnx

    Reply to this comment

  27. Ronnie on September 20th, 2007 1:35 am

    Hi All,

    This is my first post in this forum though I have visited this forum very often. And I am now tempted to give my perspective for whatever its worth :)
    I hear a lot of debate about who is good and who is bad, who is obnoxious, who is the best. And everywhere I feel that there is an attempt to a)promote ones personal favourite b)humiliate
    the next strongest contender.
    Now we are left with 4 last people and I feel that each one of these are equally strong competitor to each other. And each one of them have their strengths
    and areas of improvement. Lets not forget that no one is perfect and it is very easy to blow out of proportion the development needs of one person thus making
    him look like a completely inadequate.

    And I also hear some very strong statements where people are talking about ignorant naive janta voting out good contestants and I want to raise some fundamental question here–
    Who decides who is good and how is it decided. The people who raise this are actually patronising the same system they are criticising. Because if you want to be
    fair that how can you decide now who is the winner? Because winning would be decided by performances and not by potential. You dont pass an exam only because you know everything, but you pass an exam because you are able to use your knowledge to address the questions of the examination.

    And thats the point people seem to be missing here. Everyone seems to have decided their respective winners already. But thats where teh system of voting fails.
    Ideally we should listen to each performacnes and based on the performances we should cast our votes. And I dont think anyone of us do that.

    I would request people to not get carried emotionally and wait to listen to performances and then give out their votes to the people whom they think that performed the best on that particular day and not whom they think should win.

    Reply to this comment

  28. fazy on September 20th, 2007 12:52 am

    amanat cant be eliminated :!: :!: :!: :!: :!: :!: :!: :!:

    Reply to this comment

  29. fazy on September 20th, 2007 12:50 am

    hey if amanat eliminated from d group…i’ll kill u…..i.ve voted 4 him sooooo much….plz dn let him go…… :!:

    Reply to this comment

  30. louismaxim on September 19th, 2007 11:36 pm

    Himesh & Ismail made Sumedha scapegoat to protect Aneek & Poonam with love triale which never exist. Sumedha suffered because of these 2 guy’s. I still hope Zee producers will bring her back on Public demand. Because Zee too is responsible as they allowed such love stories to be aired during the show.

    Raja (sympathy votes)
    Aneek (real talent)
    Poonam (sympathy votes)
    Amanat (minority votes)
    Sumedha (real talent)

    God does every thing for good. Now she is free to finish all her cotracts she signed with producers of Bollywood & South.

    Please dont punish Aneek for the mistakes of Himesh. We should respect the talent and not affairs.

    Now hence Sumedha is not there, I am free to watch cricket. 6 sixers of Yuvraj in 1 over, sweet revenge against England.

    Louis D’Souza
    kuwait

    Reply to this comment

  31. mirza57 on September 19th, 2007 11:11 pm

    Dear Viewers

    I have read all the above comments. Yes, I agree, HR is the main spoiler of the good show. HR has no right to demoralize any of the contestants by passing un-diplomatic remarks. HR should change its attitude and stop showing off as there’s no one who could sing his compositions. Mussarat got eliminated because of HR making him sing wrong songs. His meaningless statements and rot bla bla bla any person would get irritated. May someone let HR understand that the stage is for the singers and not a lover’s park.

    Organisers should stop HR behaving as the final authority. I strongly oppose the idea of giving wild card entry to regional language saregamapa winners into the contest where it is a open competition.

    All the participants are very good singers. I feel sorry for Sumedha but it’s a contest and the truth is only one becomes the winner out of 100/1000 so on. Best of luck to Amanat, Raja, Poonam.

    As some one said that Aneek should go out make it possible.

    Reply to this comment

  32. SREEKANTH P on September 19th, 2007 10:29 pm

    :mrgreen: :twisted: :arrow: it is sure that she is not eliminated bcoz
    on saturday :razz: epizode they r singing duet……………………………………
    so i boy with i girl
    i think AMANAT is out :roll: :cry: :lol:

    Reply to this comment

  33. SREEKANTH P on September 19th, 2007 9:57 pm

    i dont think that she is eliminated……………………….i love u sumedha

    Reply to this comment

  34. Jackburton on September 19th, 2007 8:48 pm

    Hello everybody,

    I was waiting with baited breath to know about the elimination results, since the day Bappi Lahiri gave Poonam 9 points for the song which she sang perfectly, but that whacko Bappi Lahiri, due to his own ignorance or with ulterior motives, claimed not to have heard it. I am now highly relieved to learn that Poonam has survived the elimination. From now on, I will only request that she sing only the popular songs, which majority of the people (those who don’t value good music) want to listen to or watch. Because ultimately the ignorant but dominant section of our society will decide the fate of the contestants.

    Sumedha’s elimination is also not good, but someone had to go. She is a good singer, and despite being Poonam’s fan, I like Nigahen milane ko jee chaahta hai, sung by Sumedha, alongwith Aiye Meherbaan, from Howrah Bridge.

    And, people please stop blaming Aneek for the stupidity of HR. Even Vinit was not able to shrug off HR’s nonsense in SRGMP 2005, and finally was the runner-up to Debojit. Everything happened because of HR, and this too, I am afraid, people because of the fuss created by HR, and to punish HR will try to vote out Aneek, who really is not responsible for the mess. Nothing is going to happen, HR will carry on with his antics till the end. Please people don’t punish Aneek because of HR.

    As to the issue of versatility, I don’t think any of the male contestant is versatile. Each one specialise in their own specific genre. Amanat semi-classical/Light romantic type, Musarrat NFAK sufi type (I liked his Gulabi aankhen immensely), Aneek (alongwith Vinit of SRGMP 2005) belong to the Sonu Nigam camp, Raja Sukhvinder, Kailash Kher type. In bollywood we have had only two truly versatile male singers till date, Muhammad Rafi and Kishore Kumar, and Asha Bhosle amongst female singers. Its true that Aneek has sung all types of songs, but simply singing the song is not enough, one should also be able to bring apt emotion and soul into rendition of such songs. He has great talent, and his voice throw is also good, and as some people have pointed out being a Bengali, he also has classical base. But, just compare the song Sandese aate hain from Border, sung by him to the one sung by Vinit. You will find Vinit way ahead of him, When Vinit sings he brings along the right emotion into the song, plus he can sing like sandese aaaaaatehain, not like Aneek’s sandese aate hain, pausing in between these words. Shekhar rightly told Aneek about lack of emotion or soul in his songs. His voice lahra naheen pati hai, it does produce a proper waveform.

    The only singer whether male or female who is truly versatile is none other than Poonam. Last time Shekhar told Aneek that he is the only one ready for playback. But if you recall properly Ashaji on May 18, and sometime after that upon Ismail Durbar’s requested when Vishal offered to sign Poonam, told her she is the only singer who has got the most powerful voice, and is ready for playback.

    Aneek can sing songs of other singers, not just sonu’s, but has not yet sung them the way they were originally sung. While Poonam sing every song the way they were sung by the original singer, and sometimes even bettering the orignal. Aneek is very young has still got time on his side and will definitely develop into a highly successful singer. But for now and for SRGMP 2007 Poonam and only Poonam is the best.

    Reply to this comment

  35. neeta on September 19th, 2007 8:42 pm

    hey…yaar
    kya news sunaya…I m very happy to hear tht RAJA is topped. :grin: Aur ab ek ka face dekhane layak hoga..hahahahaha……

    Plz keep voting for RAJAAAAAAAAA!…

    Reply to this comment

  36. raza on September 19th, 2007 8:27 pm

    Yeah…I guess the owner’s of the website deleated my comments from earlier. Here it is again. In the last two episode Amanat sang the best and Raja prevailed over a superior signer…Mussarat. So, one can how these naive voters…the mahority of whom will be voting for the rest of this show. Poonum is a much bigger singer than Aneek but is in the bottom 3 at the expense of these naive voters. This voting system is just pathetic…!

    Reply to this comment

  37. ishikaluvers92 on September 19th, 2007 6:48 pm

    omg i feel bad for sumadhaa she should have been in top 2 with aneek … aneek yur the best ..
    i want to see HRs and aneek’s face wen she gets out .. but yess thankfully no more luv stories .. but ANEEK SHOULD WIN .. YUR THE BEST ..no matter wat anyone says even HR idk i luv yur voicee .. omg i really liked sumadtha better than raja .. raja should hav gone hes gettin soo borin ..

    Reply to this comment

  38. aps_athiyam on September 19th, 2007 6:12 pm

    I too hate HR but lets not used too abusive language.Well its a contest..all the singers are talented n sings really well but there is only one place. It doesn’t matter who wins b’coz they all have already started singing songs in films , has been recognized except that we are yet to hear Poonam n Mussarat getting offre to sing too. Amant sings really well no doubt but everyweek has its own day…

    Reply to this comment

  39. aminali on September 19th, 2007 5:35 pm

    Why can’t you believe, paki44? This is an Indian show, with majority Indian janta and the difference between the top contestants are just hairlines. If it is a Paki show with majority Paki janta, won’t Raja or Aneek or Poonam comes out bottom 2? Nothing unbelievable!!
    My judgement is that Amanat is a very good singer. I download all his songs as well as Raja’s, Aneek’s and others and listen to them many,many times. I can safely say that the most consistant and with a melodious voice and very versatile is Amanat. But who will win is another matter!

    Reply to this comment

  40. paki44 on September 19th, 2007 5:15 pm

    i cant belive amanat was in bottom2

    Reply to this comment

  41. ultraduo on September 19th, 2007 4:49 pm

    WELL HR has all traits of a EUNUCH in him. WALKS Like One, Talks Like One, Stands Like One (see his fingers tucked in Jeans Pocket when he stands). He is a Bundle of SCAM.

    And the biggest problem is he is SHAMELESS LIKE RAKHEE SAWANT.

    Reply to this comment

  42. ultraduo on September 19th, 2007 4:45 pm

    VOTING FORMAT IS FOR CONTESTANTS WITH MONEY. THEY CAN EASILY CONTROL THE RESULTS. HIRE 10 CYBERCAFE’s and 100 youth to keep voting whole day and you will be on TOP

    Aneek tried It.
    Others are following It.
    Some has no Money To Try This.

    Reply to this comment

  43. achar007 on September 19th, 2007 4:38 pm

    Hello KLCC Boy KL,

    I don’t understand whatever you are saying - I will not stoop to your levels. I don’t think I support the kind of language you have used.

    More importantly - in a voting system it should be one person one vote. Otherwise you are flexing your money muscle, like politicians do during election for rigging.

    You should now vote for every other contestant as many times less one as you have voted for your favorite contestant to remove your rigging.

    Please do not do it - its an insult to merit of the deserving candidates.

    Remember we get what we do.

    Thanks,

    007

    Reply to this comment

  44. aps_athiyam on September 19th, 2007 4:04 pm

    I do like Raja n Amanat too infact he is better then Aneek not that Aneek is bad singer, its just that he should be more original.As for HR he really needs to be out n if he has to be there then keep his mouth shut n treat all the singers equally. I agree Aneek has become puppet of HR. He was really simple n so himself when he joined. Infact all the singers are all good singers what matters is they should be recognized even after the show. I just can’t stand HR’s attitude, his looks and his way of apperaence.He is so fake. He will treat Aneek the same way he did to Vinit, hyped first then throw him down.

    Reply to this comment

  45. rimittal on September 19th, 2007 3:37 pm

    hi friends,
    I am a great fan of saregamapa.I am happy that raja is the topper this week.I also like poonam and aneek.Aneek has only become a puppet of HR.HR should atleast become a bit dignified now.He is basking in self glory,and Aneek might lose out just because of this fact,who otherwise is the best singer of the lot obtainig this goal at such a young age.But one shouldnt be so much prejudiced and support good music,after all,each participant is putting their best effort.I personally never liked Amanat whose singing i never found up to the mark,not that i am a big judge or something ,but music when its good touches every heart.I like raja because he can really stir something inside you.

    Reply to this comment

  46. aminali on September 19th, 2007 3:01 pm

    To beingfair: As I said earlier it is of no consequence now as to who ges eliminated! But to “kill” HR, this step is necessary. No sacrifice of talent here! All those remaining are talented and, in my opinion, if you were to ask me to rank the remaining contestants, Aneek will be last. So if he is the next one to be eliminated, then it is not such a bad thing, but the good thing is to really ELIMINATE HR and shut him up permanently at least for the next episodes of the show.
    Please see my comments in a positive way.

    Reply to this comment

  47. aps_athiyam on September 19th, 2007 2:59 pm

    Its a big relief that Raja is in n that also on top ..thats a slap to HR comments. Sumedha is a good singer but here only the bestest has to stay coz. one one will win. As for Aneek I like him n hissinging but lately his behaviour is becoming oversmart n overconfedence….HR doesn’t know when to speak, what to speak n that look he has on his face whenever other ghrana sings which is really terrible. Maybe HR is trying to improve his acting for his next film.Amant shouldn’t be on bottom last , it should be Aneek.Aneek high time you shouldn concentrate on your singing n try to act your age.Congrates to Raja n WORK HARDER so that HR shouldn’t have any words to comment on you. HR also making Poonam uncomfortable..OK one , twice, thrice said about her personal life but why he is keep on dragging it again again on every show.Poonam we like you because of your singing n you sing really well.HR shouldn’t be there..he think he is the GOD n he will speak only n nobody will speak. I like Vishal n Shekhar the best. All the best to all the finalist n Raja needs to be work harder to be still on top as long as HR is there.

    Reply to this comment

  48. beingfair on September 19th, 2007 2:36 pm

    Aminali do you mean to say that you want to sacrifice a talent to shut someone up? That’s too vengeful I guess!!!

    Reply to this comment

  49. aminali on September 19th, 2007 2:22 pm

    As I said earlier, it is of no consequence that who is eliminated. All of them now are good singers and one of them will ultimately top the whole thing. Most of us sincerely wanted HR to be eliminated and our prayers were more or less answered! Now this goon will not have anything more to say on the fictitious love affair. If he wants he can now talk of his own personal love affair!!!
    The next step to really get HR eliminated is to get Aneek voted out. Not that he deserve to be voted out but only to completely shut out his guru.
    Good luck Sumedha and it was really nice to experience some of the beautiful songs you sang! May God bless you always!!

    Reply to this comment

  50. graster2007 on September 19th, 2007 2:03 pm

    Hello guys, I am joining this forum now but I have been following this show and this forum from the very start.
    Now coming to the point I would like to highlight that WE should’nt blame a person bcz of the deeds of others, as it is being done in case of ANEEK. If HR is doing wrong, let him do so bcz ONLY STUPIDS PERSISTS OVER THEIR MISTAKES. Judge Aneek as per his singing qualities.
    All are good singers at this stage of show. But for me technically AMANET is better of all.

    Reply to this comment

  51. ravisd on September 19th, 2007 1:53 pm

    I agree Sandip. I hav always felt when a gud singer was going out. I felt too bad when Toshi & Mussarat were voted out recently. But its all democracy. Sometimes I may b wrong myself in my judgment when my fav r made to walk out. By thinking I may be wrong makes me feel light. Honestly I wish the elimination stops here but again it continues and we are ought to loose our or somebody else’s fav. I try not to keep any personal attachment with any particular singer and just enjoy every singer’s performance. But its too much to be idealistic I know.

    Reply to this comment

  52. sandipb on September 19th, 2007 1:40 pm

    And Ravi,
    How many people do you think are rational like you who watch this show and vote?
    I would say only a handful!
    That’s why we have likes of Sandeep Acharya and gladly watch singers like Neehari, Hemchandra, Toshi, Amay Date, Antara voted out!

    Reply to this comment

  53. ravisd on September 19th, 2007 1:34 pm

    Do u think we sud agree that fact that ppl vote 300 times that too @6Rs per sms and whatever applicable charges??? Do go with their words Aneek’s fans also have told the same kind of statements. Lets agree to the fact that everybody has their own fav and its not correct to term others fav as wrong choice. I personally like SC Bose & Bhagat Singh and don’t like Ghandhi. But that doesn’t mean I dont deserve to be an Indian. Lets just cheer to our fav rather than passing illicit comments on the dislikes. Each one is good at something and may be weak at something else when compared with their peers.
    Ultimate talent is the one who shines after the challenge is over. However it doesnt mean the ultimate truth, bcos there are many who dont even get glimpse to perform & prove.
    I was under an assumption that I know better in music & synthesizers being appreciated for any work I do for the music dir here. But was stunned to see a small boy with a little harmonium outperform; he was able to manipulate the pitch with out pitch blend wheels (unlike synthesizers) and his chords were so perfect that I accepted to myself he was great.
    Its all the experience that matters

    Reply to this comment

  54. sandipb on September 19th, 2007 1:18 pm

    musicfan,
    Its because people like ranges22 and others don’t listen. They just want their favourite to win, no matter what!
    Read in some other forum that somebody had voted Raja 300 times and another one 250 times! For that performance?
    Amanat, Aneek, Sumedha sang much better. Did these people who voted for Raja cast a single vote for these singers?
    NO. They don’t care about good singing!

    Reply to this comment

  55. musicfan on September 19th, 2007 1:06 pm

    I am not happy with the results at all. Sumedha was good last week and should not have been voted out. Raja#1, what’s up with that? His performances from last couple of weeks has gone down hill and he still manages to be #1 :roll:

    Reply to this comment

  56. sandipb on September 19th, 2007 12:51 pm

    Ranges22. Why do you want to vote for Raja Only?
    junaidjunoon .. And for Poonam only?

    Don’t you guys appreciate good music? Vote for your favourites but also caste your vote for other contestants who sing well.
    Let the music wins.
    If you want your favourite to win under any cost then you are murdering music!
    For once, try to appreciate that all are winners and the champion is just an outcome of this contest, nothing else!
    Give your support to all so that our music industry can benefit!

    Or am I the only mad person here?

    Reply to this comment

  57. junaidjunoon on September 19th, 2007 12:46 pm

    and females rarely win talent contest.

    GOOD LUCK GUYS
    YOU ARE ALL STARS IN MY EYES

    XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

    Reply to this comment

  58. junaidjunoon on September 19th, 2007 12:44 pm

    007 totally agreed with u. its sooooo much harder for a good female singer to be appreciated. any one of the top3 males and those who left earlier have bright futures. but like u said poonam is not getting many (if any) offers for singing. therefore we should all vote her and make her win. It would do wonders for talent contests and prove that talentt really is appreciated (btw im not saying raja, amanat, annek are not talented but for someone like poonam it has been an immense journey- all things considered)

    Reply to this comment

  59. aali on September 19th, 2007 12:39 pm

    :! :wink: iam not happy that she is out but i was sure that she is not the winner… sooner or later she has to go sometime so this was the time…. for her to go……….. at least we dont have hear about that fake love story anymore hr will be very sad what will he talk about now his fav topic is finished !!!!!!!

    Reply to this comment

  60. ranges22 on September 19th, 2007 12:31 pm

    RAJA! RAJA! RAJA! Raaaaaaaaaaajjjjjjjjjjjjjjjaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa! I am so happy that Raja topped.

    Please let’s not think that we cn now sit back and be happy - it’s more than ever crucial that we keep voting for Raja.
    HE NEEDS TO WIN THIS COMPETITION!

    KEEP VOTING FOR RAJA EVERYONE AND THANK YOU FOR HAVING FAITH IN HIM!

    RAJA! RAJA! RAJA! YIPEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

    Reply to this comment

  61. sandipb on September 19th, 2007 11:32 am

    usachi1 you are right!
    “Sumedha did not come so far on her merit” alone but also because the public loved her singing!
    Please justify your reasoning!

    Reply to this comment

  62. tanishka on September 19th, 2007 11:11 am

    :smile:
    I am just happy that poonam and amanat are not eliminated

    Reply to this comment

  63. usachi1 on September 19th, 2007 11:11 am

    What about the damage which has been done ?
    Can we go retro and start all over again.

    Reply to this comment

  64. usachi1 on September 19th, 2007 11:08 am

    Sumedha did not come so far on her merit,
    but because of HR’d drama. She is equally partner in crime. And i will repeat Some very good singers were eliminated because of that.
    khasma khani… jawanni - deewani.. piece of object.

    Reply to this comment

  65. ravisd on September 19th, 2007 10:47 am

    Is it mandate to get a glory after a sacrifice always. The happiness that Raja has topped is very short lived with Sumedha being eliminated.
    I have a bag full of blames for just one person alone but will keep it to myself.

    Reply to this comment

  66. 007 on September 19th, 2007 10:46 am

    I think Poonam should win this contest. She is not getting any good offers from music directors. Instead mouli(most awful singer with mirror cracking voice i have ever seen) is getting good offers all because of bapppppi-idiot. And others are also getting like in Bal Ganesh.

    I wish her all the luck in her life. I think she is going to get the most wonderful n most best offer among all others who have got now.

    She is the real STAR. She changers her voice accordingly, adjusting it to the type of the song and she sings all types of songs. Easier to most tough ones unlike sumedha who siongs very easy songs which suits her nasal voice.

    I again say Poonam should win the contest. She is really a role model. She deserves to win.

    Reply to this comment

  67. sandipb on September 19th, 2007 10:27 am

    usachi1,
    Why should Sumeda be ashamed?
    She has given her best. Its OK if you like others better but why blame her?

    None of the contestants were/are involved in any drama. Its only HR.
    The contestants are scared to protest because this the biggest platform they have to launch their singing career and they don;t want to go against any mentor!
    Please show a little respect to all contestants!
    They really desrve it!

    Reply to this comment

  68. beingfair on September 19th, 2007 10:23 am

    usachi1, can you explain why Sumedha should be ashamed? What drama did she do? She definately is a good singer.
    Sumedha has not doen anything to be ashamed ok! It’s your problem of attitude!!!

    Reply to this comment

  69. beingfair on September 19th, 2007 10:19 am

    I feel sorry for Sumedha :sad: She is a very good singer.She has a bright future ahead.

    No matter how much some of you shout at janata, I think the elimination pattern is fine.

    KLCC boy you are in this forum only to abuse someone or the other. I guess it gives you a ‘kick’ to use bad words for others.

    Reply to this comment

  70. usachi1 on September 19th, 2007 10:18 am

    Sumedha, jawaani dewwani.
    You should be ashamed.
    because of ur drama good singers were eliminated
    and u stood there thinking u sing good.
    Good ridence.
    maybe we will c u as a 5 min etcs role as in Zees soaps.

    Reply to this comment

  71. lak on September 19th, 2007 10:13 am

    Guys after reading all the comments I am posting mine. I do agree with you on Himesh he should never be a judge. All the popularity he got he is going to loose. Most of us have made commitment not to watch any of his movies or buy his music. I like Aneek but beacuse of HR I want him to be the next to go out. Amant, Raja, Poonam you are all good singers and should be the last 3.

    Reply to this comment

  72. sheetal1210 on September 19th, 2007 9:39 am

    Hi jenny BEHEN I should not use “USS RAJA” sorry for that. But i am sure ANEEK wil do his best. DOnt hate him because of HR.

    Vote for ANeek he is second thank god ithought HR’s all foolish talks will make him down but i know there are huge fam following of ANeek who can undersatnd this.
    You knw initially RAja was my fav but after soem time i didnt like him much as Aneek. Anyway sabki apani apni pasand hoti hai…

    Chalo BYE Sheetal (USA)

    Reply to this comment

  73. jennyash on September 19th, 2007 9:20 am

    oh man this is good i am so happy i can’t describe wohoooo lovely and lovely day for me. I guess i couldn’t have asked for more.

    Raja raja raja please vote for raja he is one of the best.

    Tnx
    jenny

    Reply to this comment

  74. jennyash on September 19th, 2007 9:04 am

    hey sheetal behen raja ko harake to dekho meh bhi chalenge karti hun aap ko. kumamayo

    Thanks shukran to allah that raja is in the top. Well i would have been happy even if he was no 2 or 3 but not in the bottom man i voted yesterday almost the whole day. Sandip and Anshi this is a very very good news.

    Anshi when this news are up i just get excited and very delighted.

    Thanks you yaar. Sandip thx to you tooooooooooooo

    hurray raja wohooooooooo raja keep it up KEEP FAITH IN ALLAH AND INSHALLAH NO OBSTACLES WILL COME ON YOUR WAY .

    HIMESH BHAI KI AAB PANT BHI GAYI LOL

    tnx
    Jenny (canada)

    Reply to this comment

  75. kirankamath on September 19th, 2007 8:56 am

    The best four are in the finals.Congratulations to Amanat, Raja , Aneek and Poonam. Sumedha was a great competitor and it is no shame to lose out at this stage. She lost out to some real good singers. It is a difficult contest and to last till this stage was a big achievement. Sumedha was a good singer. She looked good and behaved in a sporting manner despite some very bad behaviour by HR who kept harping at a non existent love triangle. He encouraged a young guy like Aneek to speak rubbish as well. Amanat was more matured and took it lightly without hurting Sumedha. May god bless her with happiness and a long cherished career whichever one she chooses.
    Some of you above use foul language against contestants which are difficult to understand. If a contestant is being voted in or voted out why use bad language against them. In what way are they to be blamed.Are they not enlightening our evenings through their talent. The comments made by KLCC are not in good taste at all. Please respect the contestants as they are there because of their singing talent only. Those of who have been voted out Junaid Mussarat Harpreet etc are all equally good only that they have been unlucky to miss out on votes. They are known the world over and I am sure if they utilise their experience and the exposure they got god willing have a great future ahead of them.
    Once again sorry Sumedha and good luck to the last 4 challengers. They all deserve to be there.

    Reply to this comment

  76. sheetal1210 on September 19th, 2007 8:42 am

    ANEEK i am gujarati but i like you like anything dont worry i wil vote for you and we all family are wth you just dont worry Usss RAJA ko to harake hi rahenge…. sukhvinder ko chodke kuch nai aaata or tumne to bahut versatility dikhayi hai apane gano mei sab kuch to gaya hai bacche ne bas logo ki chodo or HRRR ki bhi mat manana he is cheater vinit ka bhi aise hi hua tha,,,, just sing for what you areeeee…ANEEK vote for aneek :smile:

    Reply to this comment

  77. sheetal1210 on September 19th, 2007 8:38 am

    :twisted: Hey dont say aneek anything ok he is the BEST he is younger than all then also he is performing so well. Bangla wale pagal nahi hai ki aise hi usko bangla winner banaya hai or HR stupid ki waje se Aneek nahi jana chahiye….hai all fans of aneek keep voting for him.
    ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK ANEEK

    ANEEK VOTE FOR ANEEK VOTE FOR ANEEK VOTE FOR ANEEK VOTE FOR ANEEK VOTE FOR ANEEK VOTE FOR ANEEK VOTE FOR ANEEK VOTE FOR ANEEK VOTE FOR ANEEK

    Reply to this comment

  78. NGL_SERA on September 19th, 2007 8:22 am

    :???: :?: :!: :sad: WHAT ABOTU AMANAT

    Reply to this comment

  79. NGL_SERA on September 19th, 2007 8:20 am

    :???: what about AMANAT???????????

    Reply to this comment

  80. rupali_k on September 19th, 2007 8:14 am

    Best wishes for Sumedha!

    The END of Love drama. No more stupid discussions on the love triangle….Thats the best thing.
    And the good thing is that we will not have to hear meaningless comments of BL.

    I am happy for Poonam and Raja. They are genuine singers of this contest.

    Next to go should be Aneek so that we can get rid of that HR (pagala kahi ka)

    Reply to this comment

  81. rupfaz on September 19th, 2007 8:13 am

    I can’t say i’m happy Sumedha is out. She really is a good singer. But who can you say is a bad singer now. They all are so good. But just to spite HR i think Aneek should be out. I hate HR and his attitude. But wish Sumedha all the best and she does have big contract with Mahesh Bhatt so she should be laughing.

    Reply to this comment

  82. sandipb on September 19th, 2007 8:10 am

    Sumeedha … all the best for your future!

    Jenny, now you can concentrate on your work!

    KLCC Boy KL … please sow some decency!

    Reply to this comment

  83. KLCC Boy KL on September 19th, 2007 8:01 am

    Himesh Besharmiyyan ki ayesi ki tayesi. Sala!

    Raja is the best. I voted for him maybe 300 times. I too wil do more.

    Himesh Beysharmiyan can go to HELL! HR can VICTIMIZE anyone, we will support him. Next I love love love to see Aneek get out of the show. Then, HR face can be hidden again in his cap, not only the hair. Hahahahaaaa….

    Sumeedha - note for you :- Bappi MOOTU will be jobless now with no SRGMP. So, he will get you some contracts alike Molly Polly. If not someone else will give you a lot of work, u r good looking na… Movie ya drama mein kaam mil jaeyga, warna nahi to Lalooji can get you in his RAILWAY laaa… I am sooo happy for Raja.

    HR, go kill yrself stupid fella. We the public of the world have sence and can think, do not need your wrongful stupid guidance. Yaaahooooo….

    Cheers from KL!

    Reply to this comment

  84. Sanjana on September 19th, 2007 7:41 am

    Best of our wishes with Sumedha.

    Reply to this comment

  85. Sanjana on September 19th, 2007 7:34 am

    Raja! Raja! Raja! Raja!

    Reply to this comment

  86. Raffuchakkar on September 19th, 2007 7:25 am

    I feel bad for Sumedha but I do realise that only one person can be the winner in the end. I wish Sumedha very best of wishes for her future.. May she get success in her career and be a very well known name in music Industry.
    I am soooooooooooooooo happy for Raja… :smile: :smile: I am going to put more efforts - last time I voted 250 times this time it definitely be lot more.
    May he emerge a winner in everybody’s hearts and in Music Industry!!

    Reply to this comment

  87. jijuantony on September 19th, 2007 7:21 am

    Happy to hear that Raja topped. Need to watch the show, just to see Himesh’s face.But unhappy on sumedha’s elimination.

    Reply to this comment

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Forum Topics



MAGICAL MENTORS
BAPPI LAHIRI
Bappi LahiriBappida came to Bollywood at the young age of 19. The first...
Know More about Bappi Lahiri 
HIMESH RESHAMIYYA
Himesh ReshamiyyaHimesh started his career with a production house which aired quite a few...
Know More about Himesh Reshamiyya 
ISMAIL DARBAR
Ismail DarbarAs far as Sanjay Leela Bhansali is concerned, Ismail Darbar's...
Know More about Ismail Darbar 
VISHAL-SHEKHAR
Vishal ShekharThe duo of Vishal Shekhar rose in prominence when they composed the ...
Know More about Vishal-Shekhar