24th August Saregamapa Challenge 2007 Review

46 Responses to “24th August Saregamapa Challenge 2007 Review”

1. gudi on September 1st, 2007 9:07 pm

   im a great fan of SRGMP from malaysia,but recently i feel that fairness is not the priority in the show.how can it possibly be?mauli,GO HOME!u dont deserve to be here.go join a rock band,u might fare well.junaid,all the best,im sure u will come up as a star one day!n so goes to harpreet,ur a real jaat!n judges,PLEASEEEEEEEEE,do not be bias in ur comments!

   Reply to this comment

2. sg2007 on August 25th, 2007 5:23 pm

   In Saregamapa 2005 Debojit got away with it because of the modification of a saying ‘Assam Meherbaan To Debojit Pahelwan’.
   The only reason Mauli is getting away with it seems to be some ‘internal favoritism’. All please observe how there is no reaction on her face when she gets the green (to go to the next round). Almost as if she knows about it beforehand….

   Reply to this comment

3. jazzy123 on August 25th, 2007 12:59 pm

   Ok PERFECT beingfair as you say you are entitled to your opinion and i am entitled to mine and i still stick by my comments, its called freedom of expression!
   SO PERFECT FAIR BEINGFAIR THE DISCUSSION FORUM IS ALL YOURS!!
   aLL OTHER FORUM MEMBERS THE DICUSSION FORUM BELONGS TO BEINGFAIR SO YOU WILL NOT BE ABLE TO EXPRESS YOUR OPINIONS!!!

   Reply to this comment

4. beingfair on August 25th, 2007 12:31 pm

   Jazzy123,
   Well If I am showing my partiality towards Aneek that’s fine at least I am not blaming others like you did. Your choice of comments (crocodile tears)was derogatory. It meant a looot! You don’t need to agree with anyone’s opinion. I expressed my opinion that it is disgusting no matter what you say.

   Reply to this comment

5. jazzy123 on August 25th, 2007 11:34 am

   beingfair firstly i have never mentione Aneek and staight away you have shown your partiality towards Annek so you can hardly accuse me being blinded my own partiality!!i think you must be related to the goons called the mentors and really you do not have any points to back up your arguements that is why you are hopping made abt my comments! you must really be either very naive or turning a blind eye to the open an overt bias going on
   so i would prefere to agree to disagree with you opinion and vice versa

   Reply to this comment

6. beingfair on August 25th, 2007 11:22 am

   Jazzy123 for your kind information neither do I belong to either of these countries I am stating what is clear from the show. So if you yourself are partial don’t blame the judges. First accept your own dirt than dish out the dirt of the judges.Aneek is much better than Junaid so there is no question of Mauly here. YOu are just trying to bring Mauly issue here because you don’t have any other points to back up your comments!Crocodile tears! I don’t think any participant was showing crocodile tears there. when you said that it did sound disgusting.You may not accept it.

   Reply to this comment

7. jazzy123 on August 25th, 2007 11:06 am

   sandipb and beingfair you very conveniently FAIL to notice that i said ALL contestants and did noy signal any one of them!

   Reply to this comment

8. jazzy123 on August 25th, 2007 10:54 am

   sandipb and beingfair the truth always hurts!!!!!! and for your kind information i do not belong to either of these countries i am just stating the obvious!!!!!!!! you have shown your true colours!!!! and it is the likes of you both that have double standards, there is nothing disgusting in anything that i have posted otherwise the comments would have been edited so in my opinion you are the ones that are disgusting and taking up space with your biased rubbish!!! so if you want to dish out dirt learn to accept it as well!! as for being partial yes i am because a good contestant has been eliminated to keep trash in voted by the likes of you!!! a better participant than Junaid i presume you mean the tuneless mauli!!!!!!!

   Reply to this comment

9. beingfair on August 25th, 2007 10:17 am

   Jazzy Sandip is right! you talk in such a disgusting manner.Isn’t it a partiality that you want Junaid to stay in the show no matter what? There are many better participants than Junaid. DOn’t watch this show period.

   Reply to this comment

10. sandipb on August 25th, 2007 9:44 am

    jazzy123, you are disgusting!
    If this show is worthless don’t watch it and don’t fill up this discussion board with junk!
    This was a very good concept created by zee tv and all new things have bumps on the way.
    Please tell your singers not to participate in future episodes ( and forget about money and fame)!
    As for crocidile tears, I wonder how many of you shed these tears when Abhijit and Joy were out! Oh! I forgot! They don’t belong to Pakistan!

    Reply to this comment

11. jazzy123 on August 25th, 2007 9:28 am

    a word abt ALL the other contestantS and thier crocodile tears of last week… didnt see any of them crying thier hearts out at Junaid’s elimination!!!! the gits were releaved that a strong opponent got the boot!!!! who what commardship…I THINK NOT!

    Reply to this comment

12. jazzy123 on August 25th, 2007 9:18 am

    Guys the bottom line is lets stop wasting our money and time on this shitty programme and for our sanity watch something useful and meaningful. all we are doing is linning the pockets of these biased worthless mentors and the creditless ZEE tv

    Reply to this comment

13. jazzy123 on August 25th, 2007 9:06 am

    Hi Beingfair im sorry but i disagree with you, since the salman khan episode and the response that Junaid got from everyone VS have not supported or encouraged Juanaid in any shape or form , thier focus has been on Raja and Harpreet, there has been very strong partiality towards Junaid from them and no one deny that. in reality since that episode they should have challenged thier efforts towards Junaidas they have done for the other two. reaging the review Raja’s performance wasnt anythig special but did VS acknowledge this>>> NOOOOOOOOOOOOO

    Reply to this comment

14. Nick on August 25th, 2007 8:48 am

    zee tv n judges showed their big hearts n feelings for paki boys they did a fever to junaid gave him one more chance but what happend this week? it was dicided last week i knew it after listining his qawwali ( hum kisi sey kum nahi )
    but junaid you did good job. judges need mauli for their own entertaintment. they always say to mauli that you were outstanding. i have no knowledge about music compare to all judges if i can see the differance why they dont! be fair judges you are hunting voice of world not voice of india. you have no right to invite singers from other country and insult them your say n do are not the same

    Reply to this comment

15. beingfair on August 25th, 2007 8:27 am

    I mean may be the voting pattern was partial.

    Reply to this comment

16. beingfair on August 25th, 2007 8:26 am

    Hi Jazzy123,
    The judges have their own strategies of evaluating the contestants I don’t know what they are or how it works. Most of the time I have seen them praising every participant after the individual performance. They do give negetive comments at times. It’s not only for Junaid, VS did it for many contestants. For example he pointed out to Raja for reading from the palm, he gave many ‘not so positive’ comments to Mauly too if u saw the first few episodes. The point is that I don’t think that they did partiality with Junaid. May the voting pattern was partial.

    Reply to this comment

17. jazzy123 on August 25th, 2007 7:32 am

    Hi beingfair what is there in this show to enjoy, one mentor declares a winner, the other says vote for mussarat if you like his sort of voice ( this is from the person who is supposed to be his mentor! good way of saying not to vote for him!!)another mentor licking the worst contestent from head to too dispite knowing the unbelievable disgusting low quality of singing and finally VS once again publically degrading Junaid by telling him that the Janta made the rite decision because his performances havent been up to the mark.. HELLO WHAT ABT THE APPAULING DOWN MARKET SCREAMING FROM MAULI EVER SINCE THE START OF THE SHOW!!! WHEN SHE WAS SAVED HOW COME THE SAME STATEMENT WAS NOT MADE THEN ABT THE JANTA MAKING THE WRONG DECISION???? and the iceing on the cake with Junaid been compared to harpreet when he is been given the boot after giving an outstanding proformance!!
    until these so called mentors put thier predjuices behind them the show will not be seen as a credibleworthwhile show to watch

    Reply to this comment

18. Jennefer on August 25th, 2007 4:07 am

    Ok, it doesn’t matter. JUNAID ROCKS. He doesn’t have to worry about anything. He is already a great singer. All of them there can sing different types of songs very beautifully, so it doesn’t matter who is no.1 and who isn’t. But I WILL DEFINITELY MISS JUNAID’S PERFORMANCES A LOT!

    Reply to this comment

19. beingfair on August 24th, 2007 9:20 pm

    Hey everyone. Pleeeeeaaase lets enjoy the show and not bring country issue here. Please lets enjoy the songs, the presentations, the gossips, jokes, etc. Why are we finghting over the countries? Whoever will be the winner won’t even care who faught for him or who didn’t. He will have a ball, make money and will be a big guy and we will walk away simply with a bitter experience of such bad comments. Let’s all enjoy the show…comeon….!!!

    Reply to this comment

20. sandipb on August 24th, 2007 8:34 pm

    To Lone warrior,
    It has nothing to do whether its in USA or India. Its all about public voting and that too by a few people who do not understand music but have enough money to vote!
    And please don’t talk about Pakistani singers and Indian singers. Our film industry has invited and shown respect to quite a number of pakistani singers (though I am not sure how many indian singers have made it to Pakistan film industry, or even invited!).
    Sorry, inspite of Aanshi requesting not to bring up the country issue you people are always bringing that up!
    And if you judge all of us by those few people who have money and want to promote singers of their own community then please feel free to do so.
    You won’t be doing any good to this concept, but definitely going to harm it in future.
    The choice is yours now.

    Reply to this comment

21. drdeol on August 24th, 2007 5:13 pm

    after many bad performance Mauli still there,HR keep harping on her first performance,why no one talks about her bad ones and Bappi, what can i say Frankly i’m not against Junaid getting eliminated but i’m against Mauli being still there.SRGMP has become a joke The only way is to boycot by not votting as your votes are not going to make a difference as the directors has decided who the winner

    Reply to this comment

22. 007 on August 24th, 2007 4:58 pm

    Junaid was really a very good singer. I’m not satisfied with the result. Instead mouli should have gone. These mentors are gone crack. They are like crouded sheep. If one says “baa� then all others foll it. Especially bappi is so kanjoose in giving marks to other gharana conestants. Shame on him. mouli just knows to shout. I don’t know from where she gets so many votes even after so many bad performances. She is the worst singer I have ever seen. She is just there coz of her sex appeal not for her voice. They vote for that I’m sure.

    Or there is some fixing in saregamapa. They don’t take votes given to other contestants, they only take votes given to mouli. She was supposed to go along back but some how she is still there.

    She isn’t serious about her singing. Its clear from her acts.

    People in US just vote only coz she is from USA.
    But they shouldn’t be even so BLIND that they vote for such a worst singer. They should think that she came till here thats MUCH MUCH more than what she was supposed to get. I just want to ask u people-WHAT WILL YOU GET IF SHE WINS?
    when all know she is a worst singer till now.
    If a good singer wins atleast we’ll be able to listen to good voice in future.

    I request all the voters from all over the world to vote for the good, genuine, versatile, dedicated singer. I mean who really deserves that. And I’m sure its not mouli. Because of her good singers should not be eliminated.

    Reply to this comment

23. the lone warrior on August 24th, 2007 2:29 pm

    sandip that show was in US… n this is happening in india there is big diff… but we are saying are facts… judges have also stopped encouraging pakistani singers…

    Reply to this comment

24. sandipb on August 24th, 2007 2:11 pm

    Dear jenny,
    I really can’t say. But I am talking to my friends in India, and the the way the voting trend is going I am 90% sure that Raja and Mauli will be in the finals! And I said that in the very begining!
    Don’t worry about Mussarat, he will keep his mark in Bollywood music industry with Amanat.
    I told you about Raja long time ago remember? And now he is singing for Bappida.
    I won’t be able to tell you about Mussarat right now, but please trust me.
    One of my friends works with Bappida as an assistant music director and I do get a lot of info from him.
    Trust me please! Forget about SRGMP championship!

    Reply to this comment

25. jennyash on August 24th, 2007 2:04 pm

    sandip who so u think than its the winner ?
    will nay one of pakistani be a winner ?

    Sorry sandip but i am pissed off. Why call pakistani’s and then eliminate why waste my time on this

    i am so done

    i understand your point but can u help me here

    mussarat is a gem os a singer and i now really wnat him to win. whats wrong with mussarat ?

    don’t get me wrong?

    thnx
    Jenny

    Reply to this comment

26. sandipb on August 24th, 2007 1:51 pm

    Dear jazzy123,
    If you are a regular follower of this site then you would know that I mentioned about this format long long ago.
    SRGMP has lost all credibility when they introduced public voting!
    A person with money and the power to vote for his/her favourite contestant does not necessarily means that he/she is musically oriented!
    Before the public voting was introduced great musicians used to judge singers and that’s why Amanat’s father and uncle were winners. (by the way dockaul your example of Debojit is in bad taste. Winners can also be great singers e.g Sreya, Soham and others).

    The point I am trying to make and also mentioned long time ago that Zee tv cannot do anything.
    If I am a Mauli fan (god forbid!) and have money, I can vote for her 1000 times which accounts for 1000 normal people who genuinely love music but don’t have enough money to vote!
    Now, do you see my point?
    There can be only one champion, but that does not mean others are bad.
    They all (except one and you know who) have already won our hearts!

    Reply to this comment

27. jazzy123 on August 24th, 2007 1:38 pm

    well said iniathome !!how rite you are and dear sandipb these are the hard facts not being narrow minded. reading the review and HR’s comments for mussarat doesnt it seem to you that thia is the prelude to what is coming next week?? get real my friend these are the tel tale signs of things to come next week! SO GUYS DONT WAST YOUR HARD EARNED CASH TO LINE THE POCKETS OF THIS DISGUSTING BIASED ZEE CHANNEL AND ULTIMATELY THE SO CALLED RITIOUS MENTORS!!!

    Reply to this comment

28. sandipb on August 24th, 2007 1:23 pm

    Guys, for the last time I am requesting you…cool down!
    Why are you sure that that Mussarat and Amanat will be eliminated?
    Do any of you guys know that Amanat Ali’s father and uncle have been winners in past SRGMPs???

    Don’t be so narrow minded!

    Reply to this comment

29. dockaul on August 24th, 2007 1:16 pm

    Sad about Junaid but it is better for his future.. All non winners of SRGMP have excelled. Remember Debojit ?? Kunal Ganjawala, Shekhar, were all losers.
    JUNAID U ROCK & WILL DEFINITIVELY REACH YOUR DESIRED GOALS. I would also like to protest against about the secrecy of the voting patterns. It will a complete mockery of the aims of SRGMP if a third rate NASAL NIGHTMARE continues to be in the contest at the expense of a better singers like JUNAID ETC.
    Next to go will be Mussarat followed by Amanat.. The final round should be scored by an impartial jury & 75% wightage should be given to their scores & 25% to SMS. THE CURRENT SYSTEM STINKS.

    Reply to this comment

30. sandipb on August 24th, 2007 12:58 pm

    Dear diniathome,
    Its not the “number of people” voting for Mauli , its the “mumber of votes” a few people are sending for her!
    You, I and the members of this forum cannot compete with them in terms of money

    Reply to this comment

31. the lone warrior on August 24th, 2007 12:57 pm

    ravisd its not abt amanat or raja…
    judges are very unfair to other contestants… raja’s performance was not very convincing today… aneek performed well again… but it doesnt mean that they should already decide the winner… still we have 8 weeks to go…
    why are they discouraging other singers… he was not encouraging raja but he surely was discouraging others…

    Reply to this comment

32. diniathome on August 24th, 2007 12:48 pm

    sorry by her i mean mouli

    Reply to this comment

33. diniathome on August 24th, 2007 12:47 pm

    zee tv can only see ££££££ and $$$$$$$ signs in front of their eyes, they dont give 2 shits about the way people are voting. they think we are so stupid,so far only junaid was getting the top international votes, and after her butchering the swades song she gets the highest international vote, can some1 please explain to me how she got the highest votes after that song, its all rigged zee tv have already decided who the winner is and its raja. so stop wasting your money by voting, if you must vote, use the online voting system and save your money and dont add to zee tvs coffers!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Reply to this comment

34. ravisd on August 24th, 2007 12:23 pm

    Chill guys!!! Amanat will win. If not him then its Raja

    Reply to this comment

35. jennyash on August 24th, 2007 11:51 am

    U KNOW JAZZY I AGREE WITH YOU OF WHAT U SAID. MUSSARAT AND AMANAT WILL BE NEXT. wHY CAN’T THEY JUST ALL GO OH GIVE A BLOW TO SAREGAMAPA.

    I AM SURE ANEEK WILL WIN THE COMPETITION OR MAULI TO ME IT LOOKS LIKE EVEN RAJA WON’T WIN.

    THIS IS SO RIGGED I AM NOT EVEN WATCHING AGAIN I MA NOT WAISTING MY MONEY ON THIS SHOW ANYMORE

    MAY BE I AM ONLY 1 PERSON AND MAY BE IT WON’T MAKE NAY DIFFERENCE BUT WATCH IT WILL MAKE A LOT OF DIFFERENCE AS TIME GOES BY.

    HAPPY SINGING

    Reply to this comment

36. the lone warrior on August 24th, 2007 11:35 am

    what the hell he is talking abt… he is already talking abt winner… there are still 8 contestants left in show… the competition is b/w all of them n not only b/w aneek n raja…
    this way he is discouraging other singers…

    Reply to this comment

37. jazzy123 on August 24th, 2007 11:33 am

    With HR’s comments for mussarat, i would suggest that he starts to pack his bags and then the week after amanat should do the same!!!

    Reply to this comment

38. jazzy123 on August 24th, 2007 11:28 am

    how big of vishal to say hats off to junaid….how hypocritical can you get!! if VS had actually bothered to support Junaid as they have done raja and harpreet then he would not have been eliminated!! You will get more enough work back in pakistan!! IF YOU ARE READING THIS JUNAID GO HOME WITH YOUR RESPECT AND DIGNITY BEFORE YOU GET DEGRADED AND HUMILIATED FURTHER!!

    COMMENT EDITED

    Reply to this comment

39. the lone warrior on August 24th, 2007 11:26 am

    what the hell he is talking abt… he is already talking abt winner… there are still 8 contestants left in show… the competition is b/w all of them n not only b/w aneek n raja…
    this way he is discouraging other singers…

    Reply to this comment

40. sandipb on August 24th, 2007 11:25 am

    Junaid will bounce back in music industry, don’t worry.
    Have a long term vision folks. We need good singers, not just champions!

    Reply to this comment

41. Aanshi on August 24th, 2007 11:22 am

    Even I felt this today.. Vishal Shekhar are praising Raja more than necessary.. He is good but was not that good today.. It is just my opinion..

    You guys tell me after watching the video.. Will wait for you opinion..

    Reply to this comment

42. ravisd on August 24th, 2007 11:20 am

    I stopped watching after Aneek’s performance as I dont wish to see anybody going. We lost a gem. Lets pray we will cross paths somedays in future

    Reply to this comment

43. the lone warrior on August 24th, 2007 11:10 am

    i like u ismail… vishal should stop being unfair to other contestants… the competition is not between aneek n raja… actually amanat is even better than raja… n the winner should be amanat or aneek… raja is overhyped by zee n judges n they should stop doing it if they really want a deserving candidate to win…

    Reply to this comment

44. the lone warrior on August 24th, 2007 11:05 am

    hey i hate vishal n shekhar coz they always praise raja more than he deserves specially when he doesnt perform well… they should stop doing it…

    Reply to this comment

45. Jennefer on August 24th, 2007 10:50 am

    NO!

    Reply to this comment

46. Jennefer on August 24th, 2007 9:41 am

    Hi, I’ve read a lot that Junaid is getting eliminated….plsssssssssssssssss don’t write that this is true. I can’t see it. He can’t be out yaar!!!! PLSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

    Reply to this comment

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.